1. Battle of Dale: Things were looking grim for everyone in Middle-earth until
Frodo reached Mount Doom and the Ring was destroyed.
Yes, and particularly because there was no hope of rescue by any other
army. With Gondor tied up down south, everyone else was on their own.
3. Under Siege: what do you think it was like for the Dwarves and Men
sequestered together in the Lonely Mountain?
Well, they had water, and whatever provisions they had stored against a seige,
but it is doubtful whether they had much warning of the attack, so there
couldn't have been much provision.
4. Endure: How safe were they? How long could they hold out?
Until the wine/beer ran out. Or a couple hours later, at the most.
4. Battle of Dale: Any comments on the Battle of Dale in the War of the Ring?
I remember being surprised when I first read the Appx and saw this. It
had never occurred to me that other kingdoms were having big problems, and that
Lorien and Erebor were beseiged. It's almost too much to believe, though,
that they both lost their leadership in the battles. That means
that essentially every kingdom in ME had a big change in command within
days.
5. Crowning: Who do you think each Kingdom sent to the crowning?
Hard to say. The text says ambassadors, which would suggest the most
important personage they could spare, but for something as important as the
ROTK, I would consider sending the new king even if he's busy getting his
administration going.
6. Friendship with Gondor: describe the relationship of Erebor have with
Gondor? And Dale’s relationship with Gondor? How deep were these Friendships?
Probably pretty deep. It can't be a coincidence that all the new kings
and leaders had some connection with Aragorn or a member of the
Fellowship. These ties of friendship would likely allow peace to
break out all over.
7. Ever after: "realms remained ever after, as long as they lasted, …" At first
the term ‘ever after’ implies the standard fairy tale ending of: ‘They lived
happily ever after’. Why qualify ‘ever after’ with ‘as long as they lasted’?
What is being implied? Is this another application of Tlien’s famous ambiguity?
It's both ambiguous, and a standard fairy-tale ending, unless you count the one
about the purse of mouse fur, which to this day I don't understand. I
think there is a wink here of JRRT reminding us that this is stuff of legend.
8. As Long as they Lasted: How long could these realms have lasted?
At least 50 or so years till people started squabbling again. Since they
are gone now, then the answer is between maybe 50 and 3000 years, which
are both the same number in geologic time.
:)
Some who wander are lost.