<<< - << Prev | Reading Room | Next >> - >>>
Message Thread - Collate Replies - Post a Reply - FAQ

• The Last Debate #1 I'm okay, you're oh so Elvish  <Kendig>  [9/14/2003 @ 22:15]  (20/85)
• By your leave... (A late comment)  <Kathira>  [9/16/2003 @ 21:31]  (0/0)
• The Streets of Minas Tirith (better late than never?)  <nerdanel50>  [9/16/2003 @ 11:12]  (0/0)
• Elves, Dwarves, pipeweed and hope  <Morwen>  [9/16/2003 @ 1:52]  (0/0)
• The Author Understood This....  <Cyberia>  [9/16/2003 @ 0:11]  (1/1)
• Ironically, few remember  <Curious>  [9/16/2003 @ 14:14]  (0/0)
• I always thought that  <mallorn leaf>  [9/15/2003 @ 11:44]  (0/0)
• Dwarven crustiness, Trading Spaces, and Guarded Optimism  <drogo_drogo>  [9/15/2003 @ 11:35]  (0/0)
• Gimli the jew?  <Fisher>  [9/15/2003 @ 9:20]  (4/58)
• I'm speechless.  (No Text)  <Fisher>  [9/16/2003 @ 13:20]  (0/0)
• Letter 176  <Atlas>  [9/16/2003 @ 0:48]  (0/0)
• “The dwarves of course are  <Curious>  [9/15/2003 @ 11:03]  (4/54)
• Other Semitic languages in Middle-earth  <Alveric>  [9/16/2003 @ 6:04]  (0/0)
• some thoughts on the "racialism" issue  <drogo_drogo>  [9/15/2003 @ 15:50]  (1/10)
• The original dwarves  <Curious>  [9/15/2003 @ 16:10]  (2/9)
• to clarify...  <drogo_drogo>  [9/15/2003 @ 20:05]  (1/6)
• From Letters and the Interview...  <Atlas>  [9/16/2003 @ 1:31]  (1/5)
• few things to add  <drogo_drogo>  [9/16/2003 @ 10:56]  (2/4)
• Who does  <Curious>  [9/16/2003 @ 18:02]  (0/0)
• I don't think  <Curious>  [9/16/2003 @ 11:17]  (1/2)
• Some quibbles  <Atlas>  [9/17/2003 @ 2:17]  (1/1)
• I  <Curious>  [9/17/2003 @ 9:39]  (0/0)
• Casual violence, slavery etc  <Gwynfor>  [9/15/2003 @ 18:46]  (1/1)
• The fact  <Curious>  [9/16/2003 @ 11:23]  (0/0)
• On the other hand, as Tolkien's next sentence might imply,  <NZ Strider>  [9/15/2003 @ 14:40]  (1/1)
• But don't you find  <Curious>  [9/15/2003 @ 15:32]  (0/0)
• Tolkien loved the Dwarves....  <Golfimbul>  [9/15/2003 @ 11:39]  (2/39)
• I'm not sure it's about 'love' or otherwise . . .  <Pukel-man>  [9/15/2003 @ 13:29]  (2/28)
• Tolkien himself later felt  <NZ Strider>  [9/15/2003 @ 14:53]  (0/0)
• And even flattering portrayals,  <Curious>  [9/15/2003 @ 14:19]  (1/26)
• stereotyping isn't all bad;  <gullygilly>  [9/15/2003 @ 16:30]  (2/25)
• I don't agree with your analogy . . .  <Pukel-man>  [9/15/2003 @ 16:57]  (2/18)
• errrm, about genetics...  <Arquen>  [9/15/2003 @ 18:16]  (1/16)
• Huh?  <Pukel-man>  [9/15/2003 @ 18:45]  (3/15)
• Perhaps to simplify...  <NZ Strider>  [9/15/2003 @ 20:27]  (3/11)
• If I didn't know better, NZ,  <Roheryn>  [9/16/2003 @ 23:14]  (1/1)
• Thanks!  <NZ Strider>  [9/16/2003 @ 23:28]  (0/0)
• Thanks, although . . .  <Pukel-man>  [9/16/2003 @ 4:34]  (2/7)
• and begging to differ...  <Arquen>  [9/16/2003 @ 11:56]  (1/5)
• Hang on...  <Roheryn>  [9/16/2003 @ 23:00]  (2/4)
• But the point is...  <Arquen>  [9/17/2003 @ 0:02]  (1/2)
• Hang on, again.  <Roheryn>  [9/17/2003 @ 1:43]  (1/1)
• Forcibly dragging in the original subject:  <Arquen>  [9/17/2003 @ 11:52]  (0/0)
• I was hoping  <NZ Strider>  [9/16/2003 @ 23:13]  (0/0)
• We're in full agreement.  (No Text)  <NZ Strider>  [9/16/2003 @ 5:01]  (0/0)
• And to give  <NZ Strider>  [9/16/2003 @ 3:31]  (0/0)
• another link  <Arquen>  [9/15/2003 @ 19:23]  (0/0)
• Yes, I can.  <Arquen>  [9/15/2003 @ 19:21]  (1/1)
• I accept . . .  <Pukel-man>  [9/16/2003 @ 4:28]  (0/0)
• I completely agree  <gullygilly>  [9/15/2003 @ 17:10]  (0/0)
• A chair is a chair is  <Curious>  [9/15/2003 @ 16:50]  (2/5)
• But...  <Gwynfor>  [9/15/2003 @ 19:04]  (1/1)
• Agreed.  <Curious>  [9/16/2003 @ 10:58]  (0/0)
• By the way  <gullygilly>  [9/15/2003 @ 17:13]  (1/2)
• OT... comedy, and a history thereof...  <Gwynfor>  [9/15/2003 @ 19:08]  (1/1)
• How refreshing...  <gullygilly>  [9/15/2003 @ 21:40]  (0/0)
• Except in The Silmarillion.  (No Text)  <Curious>  [9/15/2003 @ 11:43]  (3/9)
• Belegost and Nogrod  <PhantomS>  [9/16/2003 @ 3:10]  (0/0)
• Hey, *you* spend a centuries doing business w/ pompous snobs like Thingol...  <aragonvaar>  [9/15/2003 @ 19:18]  (0/0)
• Mim the Petty Dwarf for one is a pretty nasty guy  (No Text)  <drogo_drogo>  [9/15/2003 @ 11:50]  (3/6)
• Mim...  <Gwynfor>  [9/15/2003 @ 19:11]  (0/0)
• Well, if Túrin's men  <NZ Strider>  [9/15/2003 @ 14:28]  (1/1)
• true, that was a big cultural misunderstanding (see below )  (No Text)  <drogo_drogo>  [9/15/2003 @ 16:00]  (0/0)
• There were nasty Elves and Men too.  (No Text)  <Golfimbul>  [9/15/2003 @ 13:42]  (1/2)
• cultural misunderstandings  <drogo_drogo>  [9/15/2003 @ 14:02]  (1/1)
• Much of it is cultural,  <Curious>  [9/15/2003 @ 16:22]  (0/0)
• I am too  <gullygilly>  [9/15/2003 @ 10:09]  (0/0)
• More alike than different  <gullygilly>  [9/15/2003 @ 4:55]  (0/0)
• The Odd Couple  <PhantomS>  [9/15/2003 @ 3:25]  (0/0)
• Elvishness and dwarvishness...  <Silverlode>  [9/15/2003 @ 2:26]  (0/0)
• Differences between dwarves and elves  <Atlas>  [9/15/2003 @ 2:00]  (1/1)
• I'm reminded of  <Merryk>  [9/16/2003 @ 1:23]  (0/0)
• Ack!  Um.....I have nothing to offer for this one...  <WhiteLadyEowyn>  [9/15/2003 @ 0:49]  (1/1)
• Often  <Altaira>  [9/15/2003 @ 1:01]  (0/0)
• The new and improved Gimli  <Altaira>  [9/15/2003 @ 0:42]  (0/0)
• Because everybody is staring at them.  <Arquen>  [9/15/2003 @ 0:31]  (0/0)
• This is the first time we've seen these two  <erather>  [9/15/2003 @ 0:30]  (0/0)
• some thoughts....  <wajeff>  [9/15/2003 @ 0:27]  (0/0)
• Um, sorry for not noticing that all below already pointed out "if" and "when" absence.  (No Text)  <mallorn-ws>  [9/14/2003 @ 23:13]  (0/0)
• Gimli may feel more neutral towards the Hobbits  <mallorn-ws>  [9/14/2003 @ 23:04]  (1/1)
• Dwarves and Hobbits  <PhantomS>  [9/15/2003 @ 4:49]  (0/0)
• If or when?  <Kimi>  [9/14/2003 @ 22:40]  (0/0)
• Is it significant...  <Smokering>  [9/14/2003 @ 22:33]  (2/3)
• Elf Cautiousness and Dwarf Bravado  <notlost>  [9/15/2003 @ 0:33]  (0/0)
• Uncanny  <Kimi>  [9/14/2003 @ 22:42]  (1/1)
• Ha!  So true!  <Smokering>  [9/15/2003 @ 20:30]  (0/0)

TheOneRing.net Rumour Mill's RPGBoard script (V2.22) was created by Brendan Byrd/SineSwiper of Resonator Software.  It is copylefted under the conditions of the GNU Public License (GPL).  It can be freely distributed and modified as long as it retains its GPL status.