1. Pippin is fitting into his armor. He's found his voice. Earlier he was
ordering men around-- telling them not to do anything until Gandalf comes. He's
determined that he must get Gandalf-- fight his fears and go down to the
battle. Pippin is acting more like a leader here than a mere soldier. I am
reminded of other members of the fellowship who go from follower to leader. Can
you think of any other similar examples?
The most striking example was Sam, in "The Choices..." that we discussed just
recently. He wasn't just a follower, he saw himself as a servant.
But he had to assume the greatest responsibility possible, and saved the quest.
2. In the subject heading of this post, I allude to Rath Dínen or the silent
street. How long is this street? I am reminded of the Paths of the Dead
Aragorn is facing at this same time. Is Denethor's walk into the tombs of
the Stewards and Kings of Gondor a way for Tolkien to contrast the two
leaders? Any other comments/observations on Rath Dínen?
Lacking a street map of Minas Tirith, I can only guess that Rath Dinen must be
what we'd consider a couple of blocks long... they don't have far to go, and
the upper levels don't have much space. But yet the architects must have
wanted enough length to have ceremonial processions, maybe some statues along
the way.
3. "Forcing himself on against a gust of fear and horror that shook
him almost to his knees. Pippin turned a corner opening on the wide place
behind the City Gate. He stopped dead. He had found Gandalf; but he shrank
back, cowering into a shadow."
The first two sentences have a rapid, galloping rhythm, as Pippin runs
desperately seeking help. But the rhythm stops dead with Pippin, alerting
us to the dramatic scene before us. The rhythm of "cowering into a
shadow" is a slower echo of the earlier
lines.