That's a magnificent speech, IMHO.
) How is Theoden’s casting aside of Saruman’s offer really interpreted by
his men—a sign of failure or power?
Once they're freed from Saruman's spell, I think it's interpreted as showing
their beloved king is completely free of the evil influence of Saruman.
2) When Theoden opens with, “We will have peace…” were you fooled as to
his intentions—even for just a moment? (I just personally have to add
that I found this to be one of the best “fake-outs” in the book. On my
first read, I read the first line of Theoden’s reply, and put the book down,
aghast. “Gandalf misjudged him. Theoden will turn on them!” Clever,
clever Tolkien)
I plead forgetfulness.
3) Wormtongue is surely listening just inside the balcony. What was the
effect of this conversation on him? Was he duped by Saruman too, or a
willing partner?
Good point! Probably a bit of both. He was bribed with a promise of power (and
of Eowyn). No doubt Saruman knew how to make his promises seem believable.
4) The fits and spurts of Saruman’s temper are revealing. He takes vicious
barbs at Gimli, Eomer and now, Theoden. What does this reveal (to
Gandalf) about his current state as the parley now turns towards him?
Saruman's losing the plot. I think he's got withdrawal symptoms from a shortage
of pipeweed.
---------------------------------------
_____________________________________________
Do we find happiness so often that we should turn it off the box when it happens to sit there?
- A Room With a View
