<<< - << Prev | Movie Discussion | Next >> - >>>
Message Thread - Collate Replies - Post a Reply - FAQ

• On Helm's Deep's importance  <Nightfall>  [9/8/2004 @ 5:21]  (10/66)
• Yes, how stupid PJ was, of course Shelob should have been in TTT  <Gerontius>  [9/10/2004 @ 16:08]  (1/1)
• Sarky but I agree  <MoreOrLess>  [9/10/2004 @ 16:47]  (0/0)
• A few different points  <MoreOrLess>  [9/9/2004 @ 16:39]  (0/0)
• If HD falls, MT has BIG problem at Pellenor.  (No Text)  <Tail-kinker>  [9/9/2004 @ 12:48]  (0/0)
• Of course, when Tolkien suggested  <Aerin>  [9/8/2004 @ 21:20]  (2/9)
• Remember, the context in which Tolkien made this suggestion  <erather>  [9/9/2004 @ 22:44]  (1/1)
• Yes, I mentioned this  <Aerin>  [9/10/2004 @ 0:52]  (0/0)
• The problem with...  <Macca>  [9/8/2004 @ 23:47]  (2/6)
• Keep in mind, though,  <Aerin>  [9/9/2004 @ 15:36]  (0/0)
• Also...  <MoreOrLess>  [9/9/2004 @ 8:34]  (1/4)
• I love that scene where...  <Valia>  [9/9/2004 @ 14:06]  (1/3)
• I just wish they hadn't tilted the hill so much  <Aerin>  [9/9/2004 @ 15:35]  (1/2)
• I never heard anywhere...  <adam of gondor>  [9/9/2004 @ 16:15]  (1/1)
• I think it was in Cinefex.  <Aerin>  [9/10/2004 @ 0:48]  (0/0)
• Helm's Deep's importance  <TheHolyBum>  [9/8/2004 @ 20:10]  (1/1)
• Of course, that's only in the movie, not in the book.  <Aerin>  [9/8/2004 @ 21:23]  (0/0)
• HD is MAJOR...  <Melian of Doriath>  [9/8/2004 @ 19:00]  (1/2)
• Interesting  <Nightfall>  [9/9/2004 @ 5:31]  (1/1)
• Well, if it wasn't for Pippin...  <Valia>  [9/9/2004 @ 14:11]  (0/0)
• Let me break it down for you  <Witch_King 1138>  [9/8/2004 @ 17:57]  (1/1)
• Of course  <Nightfall>  [9/9/2004 @ 5:33]  (0/0)
• Helms Deed fails, Rohan probably falls...  <Rhiandra Took>  [9/8/2004 @ 16:00]  (0/0)
• Another point ...  <cpierson>  [9/8/2004 @ 10:05]  (0/0)
• Answering both  <MoreOrLess>  [9/8/2004 @ 7:41]  (3/42)
• These were all the reasons I cited  <Aerin>  [9/8/2004 @ 17:21]  (1/4)
• Seeing the films had the oposite effect on me  <MoreOrLess>  [9/9/2004 @ 7:23]  (1/3)
• You're quite right  <Aerin>  [9/9/2004 @ 15:42]  (1/2)
• replace it with what though?  <MoreOrLess>  [9/10/2004 @ 17:41]  (1/1)
• Well, you've heard a number of suggestions  <Aerin>  [9/11/2004 @ 0:15]  (0/0)
• On your points #2,3,4  <mendil>  [9/8/2004 @ 10:02]  (1/8)
• disagree  <MoreOrLess>  [9/8/2004 @ 12:03]  (1/7)
• Note on #2 and Sam  <Nightfall>  [9/9/2004 @ 5:40]  (1/6)
• Not really a big point  <MoreOrLess>  [9/9/2004 @ 7:38]  (1/5)
• Actually it is a big point  <MoreOrLess>  [9/10/2004 @ 6:56]  (1/4)
• On changes  <Nightfall>  [9/10/2004 @ 7:31]  (1/3)
• The problem for me  <MoreOrLess>  [9/10/2004 @ 16:37]  (1/2)
• Sorry -  <Nightfall>  [9/11/2004 @ 10:55]  (1/1)
• What do you replace it with?  <MoreOrLess>  [9/11/2004 @ 11:28]  (0/0)
• On your point #1  <Cressida>  [9/8/2004 @ 9:40]  (3/27)
• I felt there was just enough of Sam and Frodo in Mordor  <Saracene>  [9/9/2004 @ 5:46]  (0/0)
• Agree/disagree  <MoreOrLess>  [9/8/2004 @ 11:43]  (2/23)
• Unfortunately, one of those elements  <Aerin>  [9/8/2004 @ 21:04]  (3/11)
• 'violence to  <Silent _ Watcher>  [9/9/2004 @ 9:54]  (0/0)
• I can understand dislike for that scene but  <MoreOrLess>  [9/9/2004 @ 8:05]  (1/8)
• Well, no, I don't think it does.  <Aerin>  [9/9/2004 @ 15:49]  (2/7)
• Ok even if you cut that...  <MoreOrLess>  [9/10/2004 @ 6:49]  (1/4)
• I cannot see  <Cressida>  [9/10/2004 @ 12:08]  (1/3)
• In comparason  <MoreOrLess>  [9/10/2004 @ 17:44]  (1/2)
• Sorry, still don't see it  <Cressida>  [9/11/2004 @ 11:07]  (1/1)
• I disagree  <MoreOrLess>  [9/11/2004 @ 16:24]  (0/0)
• that's as fine  <Merryk>  [9/9/2004 @ 23:13]  (1/1)
• Thanks.  <Aerin>  [9/10/2004 @ 0:57]  (0/0)
• yes!! agree  (No Text)  <Nightfall>  [9/9/2004 @ 5:41]  (0/0)
• Not just a hard and dangerous trek  <Cressida>  [9/8/2004 @ 12:44]  (2/10)
• Yes, and also  <mendil>  [9/8/2004 @ 13:12]  (2/8)
• I don't disagree  <MoreOrLess>  [9/8/2004 @ 18:55]  (0/0)
• It is for this reason...  <Macca>  [9/8/2004 @ 18:50]  (1/6)
• Me too.  <Valia>  [9/8/2004 @ 22:14]  (1/5)
• Liking HD  <Nightfall>  [9/9/2004 @ 5:44]  (1/4)
• What for though?  <MoreOrLess>  [9/9/2004 @ 9:08]  (1/3)
• Isengard, probably,  <Nightfall>  [9/10/2004 @ 7:35]  (1/2)
• I think that might be anticlimatic  <MoreOrLess>  [9/10/2004 @ 17:52]  (1/1)
• Well -  <Nightfall>  [9/11/2004 @ 10:59]  (0/0)
• What we got in ROTK  <MoreOrLess>  [9/8/2004 @ 12:57]  (0/0)
• Right  <Merryk>  [9/8/2004 @ 10:07]  (1/1)
• You've put your finger on  <Aerin>  [9/9/2004 @ 15:52]  (0/0)

TheOneRing.net Rumour Mill's RPGBoard script (V2.22) was created by Brendan Byrd/SineSwiper of Resonator Software.  It is copylefted under the conditions of the GNU Public License (GPL).  It can be freely distributed and modified as long as it retains its GPL status.