<<< - << Prev | Movie Discussion | Next >> - >>>
Message Thread - Collate Replies - Post a Reply - FAQ

• LOTR Movie Adaptations Essay  <JRandomRohirm>  [5/3/2003 @ 16:29]  (12/120)
• What genuinely puzzles me...  <Darkstone>  [5/4/2003 @ 15:35]  (2/15)
• I think the difference  <Serai>  [5/4/2003 @ 19:00]  (1/1)
• Good point, but I don't think that entirely accounts for it.  <Aerin>  [5/4/2003 @ 22:22]  (0/0)
• I know!  <Lord Sméagol>  [5/4/2003 @ 17:04]  (1/12)
• Well, in December I anticipate....  <Darkstone>  [5/4/2003 @ 17:46]  (1/11)
• The major TTT differences just felt wrong  <JRandomRohirm>  [5/4/2003 @ 18:18]  (4/10)
• I think it's a margin problem - Nimrodel?  <Serai>  [5/4/2003 @ 20:16]  (2/2)
• Yes, the margins must be reset.  <Nimrodel >  [5/4/2003 @ 23:34]  (0/0)
• Thanks Serai  <Mortae>  [5/4/2003 @ 20:23]  (0/0)
• I can't see the message either.  <Trixie Hobbit>  [5/4/2003 @ 20:09]  (0/0)
• I cant read your post  <Mortae>  [5/4/2003 @ 19:31]  (1/2)
• Margins Fixed, Color Adjusted  <JRandomRohirm>  [5/5/2003 @ 8:39]  (1/1)
• Much better nice posts btw  (No Text)  <Mortae>  [5/5/2003 @ 9:02]  (0/0)
• Well, so ...  <Darkstone>  [5/4/2003 @ 19:19]  (1/2)
• True - responses to art are subjective  <JRandomRohirm>  [5/4/2003 @ 19:48]  (1/1)
• Are you using a light color?  <Mortae>  [5/4/2003 @ 20:00]  (0/0)
• General Reply to All  <JRandomRohirm>  [5/4/2003 @ 10:10]  (1/21)
• Actually, the non-readers we've heard from here,  <Aerin>  [5/4/2003 @ 13:24]  (5/20)
• *puts up hand to give a face to one of non-book readers*  (No Text)  <mirky>  [5/4/2003 @ 20:25]  (0/0)
• All I'll say on the Faramir question for now...  <Cressida>  [5/4/2003 @ 17:52]  (2/13)
• Faramir Knows it's the Ring in the Cave  <Gator5000e>  [5/4/2003 @ 21:20]  (2/2)
• Well yes, and so does Boromir...  <Cressida>  [5/4/2003 @ 23:09]  (0/0)
• Nicely stated  <Mortae>  [5/4/2003 @ 22:23]  (0/0)
• I dont understand "What the ring is" part  <Mortae>  [5/4/2003 @ 18:29]  (1/9)
• Basically...  <Cressida>  [5/4/2003 @ 18:47]  (1/8)
• Well there lies a problem  <Mortae>  [5/4/2003 @ 19:03]  (2/7)
• Perhaps.  <Cressida>  [5/4/2003 @ 23:44]  (1/2)
• Gandalf didn't know it was Bilbo's ring  <Mortae>  [5/5/2003 @ 0:10]  (1/1)
• Not the attraction...  <Cressida>  [5/5/2003 @ 0:44]  (0/0)
• It's very simple, Mortae.  <Nimrodel >  [5/4/2003 @ 23:43]  (1/3)
• I actually wrote up a post  <Mortae>  [5/5/2003 @ 0:16]  (1/2)
• I'm sorry Mortae...  <Nimrodel >  [5/5/2003 @ 0:27]  (1/1)
• No worries :}  <Mortae>  [5/5/2003 @ 9:23]  (0/0)
• Nope I disagree  <Mortae>  [5/4/2003 @ 17:06]  (0/0)
• Must concur with that  <babysavr>  [5/4/2003 @ 15:26]  (0/0)
• Yes, I found that too...  <Nimrodel >  [5/4/2003 @ 13:57]  (1/2)
• Yes.  <Silverlode>  [5/4/2003 @ 14:03]  (1/1)
• Famamir is basically the leader of a combat unit...  <dudalb>  [5/4/2003 @ 16:28]  (0/0)
• My comments...  <Lord Sméagol>  [5/4/2003 @ 7:25]  (0/0)
• Thanks for your interesting essay, but...  <Mae Govannen>  [5/4/2003 @ 6:36]  (0/0)
• Well, I agree about Gollum's song, if not much else!  <Aerin>  [5/4/2003 @ 0:44]  (2/14)
• Well, like Serai, I love Gollum's Song...! Actually,  <Mae Govannen>  [5/4/2003 @ 6:21]  (3/8)
• I have to admit  <Trixie Hobbit>  [5/4/2003 @ 13:34]  (1/1)
• Interesting.  You're right about the tone of voice  <Serai>  [5/4/2003 @ 14:18]  (0/0)
• It took me a couple of viewings to come around  <hopebeam>  [5/4/2003 @ 12:38]  (1/3)
• Unfortunately, I've cringed *more* each time  <Aerin>  [5/4/2003 @ 13:19]  (2/2)
• Tee hee  <Scout B>  [5/4/2003 @ 14:08]  (0/0)
• Ooh, sorry to hear that it gets worse  <hopebeam>  [5/4/2003 @ 13:55]  (0/0)
• I love the song too!  <Lord Sméagol>  [5/4/2003 @ 6:49]  (1/1)
• Yes, all of the LOTR music is just so wonderful!...  (No Text)  <Mae Govannen>  [5/4/2003 @ 6:55]  (0/0)
• Love your footer - is it a nazblob?  (No Text)  <urbanite>  [5/4/2003 @ 0:55]  (2/4)
• Clearly, he's wearing the ring.  <Aerin>  [5/4/2003 @ 13:14]  (0/0)
• Nope, that would be this one...  <PoppyB>  [5/4/2003 @ 1:36]  (1/2)
• Red x! Red x!  (No Text)  <Serai>  [5/4/2003 @ 1:44]  (1/1)
• Really? ...*Grrrrrr*... It works for me!  (No Text)  <PoppyB>  [5/4/2003 @ 1:45]  (0/0)
• wow!  <Little Red>  [5/4/2003 @ 0:36]  (1/1)
• No reason for going to Osgiliath?...  <Mae Govannen>  [5/4/2003 @ 5:08]  (0/0)
• I think the biggest problem here...  <Nimrodel >  [5/3/2003 @ 23:03]  (2/6)
• Nim, I agree with all you said...  <EggsAndBacon>  [5/4/2003 @ 0:20]  (0/0)
• I agree with you on Faramir.  <Ariel the Tempest>  [5/3/2003 @ 23:13]  (1/4)
• Thank you, Ariel  <Nimrodel >  [5/3/2003 @ 23:34]  (1/3)
• Careful, there, Nim.  <Ariel the Tempest>  [5/3/2003 @ 23:56]  (1/2)
• And that's another reason, of course...  <Nimrodel >  [5/4/2003 @ 0:02]  (1/1)
• Yes.  <Lord Sméagol>  [5/4/2003 @ 8:13]  (0/0)
• Some thoughts on Arwen and Elrond.  <Silverlode>  [5/3/2003 @ 20:35]  (7/18)
• This is the best summary  <Princess of Geekland>  [5/4/2003 @ 9:24]  (0/0)
• This whole important point is brought out with beautiful clarity.  (No Text)  <Mae Govannen>  [5/4/2003 @ 7:08]  (0/0)
• Aren't you effectively saying that the book remains "unfilmable"?  <Bilbo's Heir>  [5/4/2003 @ 5:51]  (5/7)
• Good answers people.  <Bilbo's Heir>  [5/5/2003 @ 7:59]  (1/1)
• Heh.  Part-time occupation of mine, as well!  :)  (No Text)  <Serai>  [5/5/2003 @ 14:33]  (0/0)
• You gain and lose...  <Cressida>  [5/4/2003 @ 18:02]  (0/0)
• Why "diminished"?  <Serai>  [5/4/2003 @ 14:04]  (0/0)
• The real problem is time constraints.  <Nimrodel >  [5/4/2003 @ 10:29]  (1/1)
• And The Full historical context would drown out the main story.  <dudalb>  [5/4/2003 @ 16:20]  (0/0)
• Of course, the book as a whole in 'unfilmable' indeed,  <Mae Govannen>  [5/4/2003 @ 7:15]  (0/0)
• Very thoughtful analysis.  Thank you, Silverlode!  (No Text)  <TolkienFan>  [5/4/2003 @ 2:07]  (0/0)
• Well said, Silverlode, thanks!  (No Text)  <erather>  [5/4/2003 @ 0:36]  (0/0)
• Elrond the schemer  <Merryk>  [5/3/2003 @ 23:35]  (1/4)
• It's not so much....  <Silverlode>  [5/4/2003 @ 0:31]  (1/3)
• *chortle*  <Merryk>  [5/4/2003 @ 1:21]  (1/2)
• Ah, well....  <Silverlode>  [5/4/2003 @ 2:55]  (1/1)
• Well and kindly spoken!  (No Text)  <Merryk>  [5/4/2003 @ 19:51]  (0/0)
• Wow.  Excellent analysis.  Thanks!  :)  (No Text)  <Serai>  [5/3/2003 @ 21:53]  (0/0)
• It's facinating that...  <urizen>  [5/3/2003 @ 19:06]  (2/2)
• I do think there is a difference  <hatster>  [5/4/2003 @ 0:14]  (0/0)
• Interesting...  <Merryk>  [5/3/2003 @ 23:08]  (0/0)
• Most interesting  <gullygilly>  [5/3/2003 @ 18:15]  (0/0)
• Most of what you say  <hatster>  [5/3/2003 @ 17:56]  (0/0)
• Well, I disagree with almost everything you've said here  <Serai>  [5/3/2003 @ 17:26]  (4/31)
• ... and , well, I agree with all of yours!... And  <Mae Govannen>  [5/4/2003 @ 6:43]  (0/0)
• I like your first point  <Julie of the pointed ears>  [5/3/2003 @ 20:03]  (1/1)
• Thanks!  Glad I could provide some food for thought.  :)  (No Text)  <Serai>  [5/4/2003 @ 1:33]  (0/0)
• I disagree with some of what you've said...  <old_toby>  [5/3/2003 @ 18:31]  (2/3)
• If Elrond is self-centered...  <Nimrodel >  [5/3/2003 @ 23:08]  (1/1)
• Elves are not morally perfect beings....  <dudalb>  [5/4/2003 @ 16:24]  (0/0)
• wow I never thought of that fall  <Goldilocks Took>  [5/3/2003 @ 18:45]  (0/0)
• Could be an intergenerational conflict?  <JRandomRohirm>  [5/3/2003 @ 17:48]  (3/23)
• It must be her intense love for her father,  <Mae Govannen>  [5/4/2003 @ 6:52]  (1/1)
• I agree with you.  <Trixie Hobbit>  [5/4/2003 @ 9:03]  (0/0)
• **giggles** wow you're  <Goldilocks Took>  [5/3/2003 @ 18:36]  (3/16)
• Faramir the Not Too Bad  <LSR LVR>  [5/4/2003 @ 7:47]  (1/1)
• well said,  I understand the  <Goldilocks Took>  [5/4/2003 @ 8:47]  (0/0)
• I have to ask you, GT  <Nimrodel >  [5/3/2003 @ 23:09]  (1/10)
• Where did I say hideous???  <Goldilocks Took>  [5/4/2003 @ 8:58]  (2/9)
• OK, to offer an analogy...  <Nimrodel >  [5/4/2003 @ 10:23]  (1/2)
• A word on reading into the silences  <Serai>  [5/4/2003 @ 13:27]  (1/1)
• I greatly anticipate the EE.  <Nimrodel >  [5/4/2003 @ 14:14]  (0/0)
• Yes, it's important to care about him.  <Bilbo's Heir>  [5/4/2003 @ 9:46]  (5/5)
• It occurs to me...  (Mini-Spoiler - ROTK)  <Cressida>  [5/5/2003 @ 10:57]  (0/0)
• Oh, one other point....  <Bilbo's Heir>  [5/5/2003 @ 8:25]  (0/0)
• Approval from both Nimrodel AND Serai!  <Bilbo's Heir>  [5/5/2003 @ 8:11]  (0/0)
• Hey, that's a very good encapsulation  <Serai>  [5/4/2003 @ 13:14]  (0/0)
• Yes, that's it in a nutshell  <Nimrodel >  [5/4/2003 @ 10:11]  (0/0)
• the Granddaughter of a teenage rebel  <hatster>  [5/3/2003 @ 18:42]  (2/2)
• That is exactly what Tolkien said  <Serai>  [5/3/2003 @ 19:41]  (0/0)
• Oh very good point!! no wonder  <Goldilocks Took>  [5/3/2003 @ 18:48]  (0/0)
• First of all  <Serai>  [5/3/2003 @ 17:58]  (3/3)
• Interesting..  <Trixie Hobbit>  [5/4/2003 @ 8:54]  (0/0)
• Perfectly said , thank you!  (No Text)  <Mae Govannen>  [5/4/2003 @ 6:58]  (0/0)
• I can't agree more  (Mini-Spoiler - ROTK)  <hatster>  [5/3/2003 @ 18:37]  (0/0)

TheOneRing.net Rumour Mill's RPGBoard script (V2.22) was created by Brendan Byrd/SineSwiper of Resonator Software.  It is copylefted under the conditions of the GNU Public License (GPL).  It can be freely distributed and modified as long as it retains its GPL status.