Here it is. This is the (ongoing) Geek's List I sent to Xoanon. We
can still add to it... so feel free to keep watching and enjoying! Let me
know if I need to add, edit, or delete anything! Sorry in advance if
something's been cut or misrepresented. I have no idea who submitted
what, so let me know if something needs attention! Thanks!
Ready?
Fellowship of the Ring Movie Observations
GEEK'S LIST!
by TORn Discussion Board Members
THE PROPHECY
1) When the New Line logo appears, you can hear the same ringing sound the One
Ring makes throughout the film! VERY COOL!
2) In the film and soundtrack there are chapter titles from The Fellowship of
the Ring and The Hobbit are worked into story - From the soundtrack: "The
Shadow of the Past"; "The Treason of Isengard"; "The Black Rider"; "A Knife in
the Dark"; "Flight to the Ford"; "Many Meetings"; "The Council of Elrond"; "The
Ring Goes South"; "A Journey in the Dark"; "The Great River"; "Amon Hen"; "The
Breaking of the Fellowship"--From the film: "A Long-Expected Party"; "Shortcut
to Mushrooms"; "The Bridge of Khazad-dum"; "Lothlorien"; "Mount Doom";
"Strider"; shows the "Sign of the Prancing Pony"--and From The Hobbit; "Riddles
in the Dark"; "Not at Home"; "Concerning Hobbits."
3) The three Ringbearers you see at the beginning of the film are the ORIGINAL
three (i.e. Galadriel, Gil-Galad and Cirdan)
4) Only the Elves wear their Rings, and these Rings are not taken by Sauron
[ref: The Silmarillion]; all the Elves wear their rings on the middle finger
while Sauron wears his Ring on the Finger of Ego, the Index Finger; The Dwarves
inspect their rings then hold their Rings away from them; the Men keep their
rings close to them. They are the only group which stares straight ahead like
Zombies.
5) The Kings in the prologue stand forming a "V" shape (same formation when
they are chasing Arwen as Ringwraiths)
6) John Howe and Alan Lee are two of the kings shown in the prologue (second
from the end of each row)
7) At the beginning of the Battle of the Last Alliance, Elendil is carrying
Narsil upright before him (a theme repeated throughout the film).
8) In the Last Alliance scenes there are some very tall, wavy banners--nothing
too significant, but such a neat, nifty touch.
9) Elendil's helm is the same as the one at the Argonath.
10) There are seven stars on Isildur’s breastplate (also shows in the mural at
Rivendell)
11) At the Battle of the Last Alliance, the elven archers shoot through the
first rank of Elves holding spears.
12) Sauron's high spikes on its helm are mimicked by the Nazgul's crowns (seen
at Weathertop). They resemble the top of Barad-dur Tower.
13) When Sauron wears the ring, it's bright and the inscription is visible and
glowing read (disappears when he loses it)
14) Sauron is wielding a mace.
15) When Sauron is whacking everyone with his mace, you can see the white tree
of Gondor on the shields as they spin through the air.
16) Isildur seems to be the only left-handed guy in the whole movie.
17) Some of the stitching on Isildur's glove is broken (Base of thumb when he's
holding the ring)
18) There are many uses of "round" patterns during the prologue: rings of
water rippling in a pool, a shot of trees seen from the view of spinning slowly
beneath the branches, the flaming ball of the sun sinking below the horizon.
The scenes invoke the passage of time but also the round shape of the ring.
Later, when Frodo senses the Ringwraith on the road we see a sort of ring-like
dilation effect of the scenery. (Maybe portraying the power of the ring
reaching out to the riders or the rider is invisible)
19) Isildur, who was succumbing to the power of the ring, is shot by three
arrows in the back which is later echoed by Boromir being shot by three arrows
to the chest.
20) Bilbo is wearing Sting in the prologue when he finds the Ring (though he
had not yet named it).
CONCERNING HOBBITS
21) The wizards, as we geekier types know, were all Maiar, the lesser of the
two kinds of spirits who sang the world into existence before the beginning of
time. So what's Gandalf doing when we first see him? Singing.
22) Gandalf's silver (grey) scarf is hanging from the lamp of the cart when
coming to Hobbiton
23) When Gandalf approaches Hobbiton and when Bilbo leaves the Shire, they're
singing "The Road Goes Ever On".
24) Frodo left his book behind when meeting Gandalf. Perhaps he was at his
favorite reading spot. Then jumped off the cart to possibly return to his book
and more reading (politely giving Gandalf and Bilbo time alone)
25) When Frodo runs up to Gandalf as he stops the cart and they try to stare
each other down...Frodo wins. Gandalf breaks first. Is Frodo stronger, or was
Gandalf so relaxed he didn't give a rip? Looks like something they do every
time they first meet. "A wizard is never late, Frodo Baggypants..."
26) When Frodo was riding in the wagon with Gandalf, he said: "…we never had
any adventures or did anything unexpected." This is from the first page of The
Hobbit, describing the Baggins family.
27) Most of the hobbits are happy to see Gandalf when he arrives in Hobbiton.
They wave and call out to him.
28) There's a yellow parrot in a cage in the square of Hobbiton as Gandalf and
Frodo ride through in the cart.
29) The Hobbiton markets have large bundles of tobacco leaf hanging
upside-down.
30) Gandalf tips his hat at the townsfolk as he rides with Frodo through
Hobbiton.
31) Gandalf's wagon could barely fit onto the narrow hobbit roads and
bridge.
32) There's a road sign where the road forks.
33) The seat of Frodo's velvet-like pants are worn appropriately.
34) The notice at Bilbo's gate is attached with four nails. They have a special
square head, and today they are used mainly for attaching horseshoes to their
hoofs.
35) On the sign at Bilbo's gate, the marks above the vowels are the Tehtar
symbols for those vowels in Quenya and Sindarin. And on the sign being raised
at Bilbo's party, while the lettering style is similar, those vowel-marks
aren't present -- because the hobbit who made it wouldn't know them, of course!
Also, from what I've seen of the extended DVD footage, it looks like Bilbo
includes the Tehtar symbols in writing "There and Back Again."
36) The fence and gate at Bag End is knee high to Gandalf but chest high to the
hobbits
37) Gandalf bangs on Bilbo's front door with his staff, which irritated Bilbo
to no end in The Hobbit
38) When Gandalf is rapping on Bilbo's door you can see a small pouch hanging
off the larger pouch he carries at his side (in one of the DVD specials, it’s
hanging off his staff).
39) Bag End's front door has the knob in the center on the outside, but the
inside latch is on the right-hand side of the door.
40) There is a bird house in Bilbo's front yard (next to the bench)
41) The doorbell is to the left of the door to Bag End, and when Gandalf
enters, you’ll see the bell to the right of the door, which is exactly where it
should be.
42) In Bag End, there is dust on the floor in the places with no traffic
43) The entrance and hallway looks EXACTLY like the John Howe illustration made
years before, down to the smallest details, including the wooden beam and the
chandelier Gandalf hits his head on...
44) There are large pinecones lying around throughout Bag End.
45) Thror's map of the Lonely Mountain is still mounted in its frame from
hanging on the wall.
46) Gandalf seems like a wanderer (the pilgrim) finally coming home by the way
he looks about Hobbiton and Bag End drinking in every little detail. Probably
the closest thing to "coming home" he experiences during his time in Middle
Earth.
47) Gandalf chuckles to himself after hitting his head on the ceiling beam at
Bag End (it’s endearing to him)
48) In Bag End, there's clutter all around even little doodads on the
wainscoting
49) After Gandalf arrives at Bag End, Bilbo runs about offering him food
Gandalf requested in The Hobbit. Gandalf turned down the tea in The Hobbit, but
now he wants... "Just tea, thank you."
50) There are oversized carrots in the kitchen corner in Bag-End, and in
Merry's hand after they fall down the hill, and Pippin's pocketsesss.
51) Some relative (Lobelia Sackville-Baggins ?) knocking on the door when Bilbo
and Gandalf are talking, despite the message about no admittance except on
party business posted on the gate
52) On the fireplace in Bag-end: it's odd that a hobbit's fireplace would have
a decorative motif of reeds (looks like cat-tail's) since hobbits don't like
water as a rule. Could it be this reed design is a reference to something else:
the Ring being pulled out of the river?
53) The pictures above Bilbo's mantelpiece are of his parents, but they're
actually pictures of Peter Jackson (without his beard) and Fran Walsh (Peter's
partner and co-screenwriter).
54) Bilbo needs both hands to lift the kettle, Frodo only uses one.
55) There are candles on the walls. Where the walls are curved, there are dark
marks above where the candle smoke has discolored them.
56) Perhaps a sign of prosperity... there are candles lit EVERYWHERE at Bag
End. Even in rooms not being used.
57) There are many homey touches in Bilbo's kitchen. There's pudding with a
slice taken out on the table; a hairbrush on the window ledge; a knife resting
across jelly/honey jar on the windowsill.
58) Gandalf tries to tuck his legs under the kitchen table at Bag End. He keeps
knocking his knees.
59) Bilbo chuckles to himself when he muses that Frodo would probably "come
with me if I asked him." His voice is soft as he talks about the woods, the
fields, the little rivers (almost with regret)
60) Bilbo’s hands and fingernails are clean and well-kept, just like landed
gentry’s hands should be.
61) The pointy tops of Bilbo's chair by his fireplace looks like Rivendell
style architecture -- specifically like the top of the "church/clock tower
looking" spire.
62) There's a smoke "stain" over the hearth at Bag End.
63) Bag End door keys are hanging on the mantle.
64) There are pegs along the hallway wall with cloaks and coats hanging from
them (referencing the Hobbit as the dwarves arrive)
65) The roots from the tree above are a part of Bag End's interior.
66) In Bilbo's clutter, there are papers hanging out of the closed cupboard
doors (as if the doors were slammed shut before the papers could fall out) and
books and papers are piled everywhere.
67) Bilbo's black travel jacket is on the back of his chair (most notable when
Gandalf picks up the map of the Lonely Mountain), he puts it on after the
party
68) There's a scroll tied with ribbon on the trim above the mantle of Bag End
(a will?)
69) Bilbo keeps the One Ring in his bottom pockets of his coat, while Frodo
either has it on a chain or in his top pocket of his vest (closer to his
heart).
70) Bilbo and Gandalf are sitting on the bench outside Bag End's open front
door when blowing smoke rings.
71) After he blows his smoke ring, Bilbo watches Gandalf expectantly- they’ve
done this before.
72) As in The Hobbit, Bilbo blows simple smoke rings and Gandalf blows
intricate shapes that go through the rings.
73) Gandalf's smoke ship resembles an elven ship (swan-shaped bow--possibly
like one at the Grey Havens?)
A LONG EXPECTED PARTY
74) The fireworks tree at Bilbo's party bursts into a shower of flowers (as in
the book)
75) Gandalf leaves his hat on while shooting fireworks; it is otherwise off
during party
76) Merry is jumping and bouncing leading the two hobbits carrying Bilbo’s cake
in over the heads of the hobbits sitting at tables.
77) You can see Sam sitting and watching as the cake passes (when the hobbits
lift the cake up high, he’s sitting right from underneath smoking his pipe)
78) Frodo is the first one out ready to start dancing!
79) Gandalf neatly combs his hair and beard for Bilbo's party (brings beard to
a point at the bottom)
80) One of the birthday party band members is wearing a kilt.
81) Bilbo welcomes Fatty Bolger to his party (shakes hands with him)
82) Bilbo works the party crowd and dresses like an aristocratic
politician.
83) Shire folk have long, curved, dark pipes (Gandalf influenced--he has one,
too) while outsiders (Strider, Gimli) have short, light-colored, straight
pipes.
84) Rosie and Frodo are dancing next to Gandalf's doing a jig (way to the left
of the screen, almost out of shot)
85) Merry's standing on the stage with the band (how CAN you miss that yellow
waistcoat!) talking to Pippin -- and Pippin is sitting in with the band playing
a banjo (can also see him when Bilbo's cake is carried in) [addendum] Looking
closer what Pippin has is a mandolin neck (it has eight strings) with a banjo
body. Same tuning as a mandolin, different sound. That's not what was recorded
though.
86) Even at his own birthday party, "Uncle" Bilbo is drawn to the children and
tells them stories
87) When Bilbo is telling his Troll tale, the little hobbit children are
wide-eyed and excited but the older ones behind are merely amused--they've
heard it all before!
88) Two of the hobbit children to whom Bilbo tells his story are credited as
'Cute Hobbit Children', and are listed as Katie and Billy Jackson, who are
Peter and Fran's kids
89) There's a hobbit roaring drunk at Bilbo's party hanging off the keg! (had
to add to list cuz it's too cool!)
90) Gandalf lights off his fireworks with his staff.
91) The fireworks do a lot to develop our understanding of Gandalf. They
suggest at first that he may be little more than a "conjurer of cheap tricks",
but the beauty and complexity of the fireworks hints at his power (and that he
can set them off with a thought as he did from the wagon upon his arrival).
92) Hobbits line dance.
93) Sam and Frodo sit together at the birthday party. Sam is sitting quietly
smoking a pipe across from Frodo (who turns around for the speech) Sam’s
clothing has a more common appearance compared to the other well-to-do
hobbits
94) Sam never seems to be on the same social level as the other hobbits. At the
party he sits with Frodo and he doesn't seem to talk with anyone else. The only
one he confides with is Frodo (Frodo KNOWS how much he likes Rosie).
95) There's a tent that's set on fire after Merry and Pippin launch the rocket
and it sails past.
96) Smaug was recreated in the firework display. Secondary fireworks pop
and crack as Smaug’s wings materialize.
97) Frodo is walking behind Bilbo through the crowd when the dragon appears
(escorting him to make his speech cuz he's a little tipsy?)
98) It seems like Frodo doesn’t realize the Smaug fireworks is not a real
dragon as he’s instantly concerned for Bilbo and attempts to save him… "Watch
out for the dragon!"
99) Merry and Pippin's hair is smoking after setting off the dragon
firework.
100) Gandalf calls Sam, Merry and Pippin by their full first names.
101) Bilbo cocks his eyes and takes one last chug on his drink before doing his
speech and stands under the party tree (as in the book)
102) The hobbit that laughs at the "fireworks" children, and whose wife then
scowls at him, was not only invited to the party, but says, "ProudFEET!"
getting a big laugh from the liquored-up hobbits (or a running inside Hobbiton
joke).
103) The ring causes people to break into a sweat. It happens to Bilbo at his
party and to Frodo several times - most notably during the first encounter with
the rider, in Bree, and during the Council of Elrond
104) Gandalf sips on a tiny hobbit-sized cup at Bilbo's party
105) Sam's one of the only hobbits that doesn't applaud during Bilbo's speech.
He's puffing away on his pipe, but still smiles and offers his full
attention.
106) Bilbo's mind wanders when he's giving his speech as he thinks about
putting on the ring
107) Bilbo looks directly at Frodo when he says "Good-bye" during his birthday
speech.
108) There's the noise of feet running up steps when an invisible Bilbo is
dashing back to Bag End.
109) When Bilbo reappears inside his door after the party -- his shadow on the
door reappears with him.
110) We see Bilbo pack two candles, his pipe and his leather-bound manuscript
of "There and Back Again/Red Book of Westmarch"
111) Bilbo growls and hisses when he talks to Gandalf about keeping the ring
(gollum-like); and when he says "… my precious," his eyes get as huge as
Gollum’s.
112) It looks like a map of Middle Earth low on the wall next to the fireplace.
You can see it when Bilbo throws himself back against the wall when Gandalf
goes ballistic.
113) When Bilbo drops the ring just before he leaves for Rivendell, it hits the
floor with a loud clunk and stays put. It doesn't spin or bounce like most
rings would.
114) As Bilbo is trying to leave the ring behind... his chin quivers and hand
shakes, but he ultimately just drops it and walks away. He isn't concerned with
its safety or what was to become of it. He is immediately free enough from its
influence to think of his book and a very positive ending to it.
115) As Bilbo leaves Bag End, his hair is still standing up in the front from
being blown by Gandalf's temper flair.
116) Bilbo has the same small black pot hanging off his pack as Sam’s.
117) Hobbit hands are notably smaller whenever touched or held by anyone
else.
118) Many of the characters speak lines from other characters and/or places in
the book.
119) The pattern on Frodo’s party vest resembles artwork of flowers Tolkien has
drawn (found in book entitled "Pictures by J.R.R.Tolkien")
120) There's a quiet slapping on the floor of Frodo's feet as he walks up to
Gandalf.
121) Gandalf is surprised that Frodo can handle the ring unaffectedly as he
carries it from where Bilbo dropped it.
122) Gandalf very subtly manipulates Frodo into hiding the ring away by holding
out an envelope as he talks leading Frodo into dropping it in. He quickly seals
it shut with a wax seal (in other words...don't handle it) and tells Frodo to
keep it secret, keep it safe.
123) When Gandalf is holding the envelope, it looks small; when Frodo holds it,
it looks more "hobbit sized".
QUESTIONS THAT NEED ANSWERING
124) As Gandalf rides up, we see the first view of (an unnamed) Minas Tirith
facing Mordor and a fiery Mount Doom. You can see how close Mordor is. Good for
perspective of danger.
125) The city of Osgiliath is visible at the bottom of the screen, way off in
the distance, with the river Anduin running through it.
126) There's the handle of a shovel or rake leaning up against the wall as
Gandalf walks past the two men sitting and talking in Minas Tirith.
127) Gandalf sets his hat on top of his staff while in the Minas Tirith
library.
128) Gandalf holds his pipe between his fingers while still rifling through
parchments in the library.
129) Two of the maps Gandalf flips past are of Forde and Fenmarch (in
southern Rohan below Rauros) and the other is of Ithilien.
130) When Gandalf is reading the account by Isildur concerning the ring, the
parchment is transcribed faithfully as it was written in LOTR! But Gandalf
doesn't read exactly what's written.
131) Molten lava pours down from Mt. Doom along an aqueduct that fills a moat
surrounding Barad-dur.
132) There are torch lights streaming towards the black gates. The enemy is
moving.
133) When the hobbit is chopping wood, we see the shadow of the approaching
Wraith and horse on the cottage walls before the scene cuts to a close-up of
the actual Black Rider. Then we see the shadows of three Black Riders flicker
across the side of the cottage in the dying rays of sunset as they speed away.
THE SHADOW OF THE PAST
134) Sam can’t look away from Rosie when saying goodnight. He has a lingering
smile as he walks away.
135) Why does that hobbit (Frodo) never shut the door behind him!? Gandalf has
mud caked on his clothes/boots from his hard ride back to Hobbiton.
136) When Frodo is reaching into the chest for the envelope containing the
ring, the angle is very similar to the "ring's eye view" when Gandalf first
tries to touch the ring as it lies on the floor of the entry way and when
Gandalf is pulling the ring from the fire.
137) As Frodo is looking for the envelope holding the ring, Gandalf is startled
by the croaking noise outside the window because it sounds like an orc.
138) When Gandalf throws the envelope with the ring into the fire, he glances
back at Frodo nervously when he walks up and asks "What are you doing?" Was
Gandalf already concerned at what Frodo might do if he thought the ring was
being harmed?
139) There is ash on the Ring when it is pulled from the flames.
140) The ring reflects the fire as it sits on the table in Bag End when Gandalf
is explaining its history to Frodo. Interestingly, it doesn’t reflect anything
else.
141) Frodo's cup has steam rising from it.
142) Bilbo's table was laden with pastries and cheeses. Frodo's table has more
fruits on it.
143) Both Frodo and Gandalf hear the ring whispering at the table. The
only time more than one person hears the ring at the same time.
144) The ring has a low-decibel ringing sound when Frodo's holding it in his
hand extended out to Gandalf, and is suddenly stifled when Frodo closes his
hand and says, "What must I do?" It also makes that ringing sound when he
places it on the pedestal at Elrond's Council and just before Bilbo pulls it
from his pocket just before he drops the ring onto the floor.
145) Frodo roughly unfolds and jams his shirt into his pack that Gandalf has
neatly rolled.
146) When Frodo is packing to flee the Shire, he goes into the kitchen for
food. Its ceiling has tiles instead of plaster like the rest of the rooms.
147) Frodo packs two shirts, two apples, and a loaf of seed cake. He doesn't
plan to be gone very long.
148) Gandalf specifically tells Frodo to stay off the road. Sure enough, it's
when they hit the road that they get into trouble.
149) There are two different walking sticks used when Gandalf hands it to
Frodo. One with a smaller grip for Gandalf, and one with a larger grip for
Frodo as a perspective on size!
150) Always thought that the act of Gandalf giving Frodo his walking stick was
symbolic of Gandalf handing over his wizard's staff to a young apprentice. Kind
of like passing the torch - 'you have to bear this burden. I cannot take it for
you.
151) The thunk of Frodo’s walking stick hitting the ground when Gandalf tells
him to get down.
152) Gandalf slaps his staff from his left hand to his right when he's about to
do battle (before hauling Sam through the window and again when he’s about to
fight with Saruman)
153) I think that when Frodo hears the squeal outside the window, he recognizes
that it's Sam.
154) There's intricate designs on Bag End's carpet (we see it when Gandalf
slams Sam down on the table) and a beautiful herring-bone hardwood floor.
155) At first, it looks like Gandalf has turned Sam into the horse he's
leading. "Keep up Samwise!"
156) There's an ineffective scarecrow in the field when Sam and Frodo are
leaving The Shire - birds are perched on it (tribute to Hitchcock’s The Birds?
Or maybe The Wizard of Oz)
157) Sam is so distraught at leaving the Shire, he's huffing and puffing as he
takes "one more step" and crosses that point where he's "the farthest from home
I've ever been." Poor Sam. Frodo helps by reminding him of what Bilbo
used to say (as Frodo's voice changes over to Bilbo's)… "It's a dangerous
thing, Frodo, going out your door..." (Sam always enjoyed Bilbo's
stories)
THE TREASON OF ISENGARD
158) As Gandalf rides toward Orthanc, there are some posts chained together
along the side.
159) We get an aerial shot of the land surrounding Isengard, green with trees
and grass. Later we see that same area devastated and dead from Saruman's
work.
160) Saruman's staff is the same four-pronged shape as the Tower of
Isengard.
161) The design in the windows of Orthanc is based on the tower seen from above
-- a circle with four horns extending outward.
162) Gandalf keeps his pipe in the top of his staff
163) Gandalf doesn’t put his staff down when at Isengard (like he does at Bag
End and Rivendell)… instinctively knew he needed to keep it close?
164) Saruman has specimens in liquid-filled jars. Was he already experimenting
to create his Uruk-hai?
165) Gandalf's left eye is bloodshot (like it was injured when he's about to do
battle with Saruman. Aragorn also has a bloodshot right eye when they're
on the River Anduin about to approach the Argonath. (left over from a surfboard
battle?))
166) As Gandalf is forced up to the top of the tower, his cry echoes into the
scene where we see Frodo and Sam in the cornfield, as if to foreshadow that
Gandalf's delay will have a dire effect on the hobbits.
THAT WAS CLOSE!
167) The line Sam delivers in the corn row about not leaving Frodo, is actually
what Gildor told him in the book when they meet with the Elves at Woody End. In
the film Sam attributes that advice to Gandalf.
168) There's the sound of Sam's clashing pans and utensils whenever he
moves.
169) Due to hobbit stealth, Frodo and Sam didn't even hear Merry and Pippin
running towards them through the cornfield until they collided. Sam's strength
is shown when he picks Pippin up by the collar off of Frodo in the
cornfield.
170) Sam picks up Frodo fairly lifting him off his feet. Strength he'll need
soon enough.
171) Farmer Maggot's scythe resembles an Uruk-hai blade.
172) Farmer Maggot's dogs are audibly in pursuit of the Hobbits, along with
their angry master. The barking reminds the boys to RUUUUNNNNNNN for it!
(Pippin’s already gone!)
173) After the hobbits fall down the slope running from Farmer Maggot, Pippin
says, "Oooh, that was close" because he's fallen face to face with a steaming
pile of droppings just in front of his face. (Hmmm, is that from a Black
Rider's horse?!?-wonder how many piles of dung they tried before they picked
that one?)
174) There are carrot tops sticking out of both Merry's waistcoat pockets as
they run to get off the road. There are carrot and apple issues
throughout the film!
175) Closeups of the hobbit feet show them always dirty, as would be
expected.
176) Frodo is the only one not rushing over for the mushrooms with the other
hobbits, he’s distracted. He senses the approach of something and sees a
distortion down the road (Could it be an invisible Black Rider?).
177) Frodo's first instinct is to hide (as hobbits do).
THE BLACK RIDER
178) The Nazgul's horses have coal red eyes
179) As the Black Rider approaches the hobbits under the tree, there's a
flutter and rustle of leaves as the birds and beasts flee... then silence.
180) As the hobbits are hiding under the tree root, we hear the Ringwraith's
horse approach from the right of the screen but don't see it until it has
passed to the left of the tree (remember we can see to either side of the tree,
right and left). We don't see the horse approaching the right side of the tree,
it sort of magically appears on the left coming from behind it.
181) The odd-angled nails in the Ringwraiths' horses' hooves; they look like
they were just slammed in any old way.
182) You can see the blood or sweat running down the Nazgul's horse's leg (when
the hobbits are hiding under the tree root)
183) The Nazgul's clothing has frayed edges. Sauron's were frayed as
well.
184) The Nazgul horse snorts when the Nazgul is smelling for the ring... they
are in sync somehow
185) The trunk of the tree where the hobbits hide has a huge, heart-shaped
knothole. It covers the whole side of the trunk.
186) When the first Black Rider appears and zeros in on the ring, the insects
emerge and flee from the dirt and wood.
187) The supernatural speed of the Nazgul when he leaps to follow the sound of
the bag of mushrooms that Merry throws.
188) After they escape the Black Rider from under the tree and a dazed Frodo
holds the ring and looks at it, it's the only time it's seen from his
perspective. The rest of the time when he holds it out in his hand, it's seen
from other's perspective/angle. Frodo is shocked as he perceives the ring's
influence over him. He's starting to realize the deeper danger.
189) Another carrot sighting: in the woods after nightfall, jus before someone
says "Anything?" and Frodo replies "Nothing," Merry is silhouetted for a
moment, and you can see the leafy tops STILL sticking out of his
pocketsess.
190) Merry very quickly puts together that the black rider is after something,
or someone... and he challenges Frodo with that question. Frodo's afraid
to answer (keep it secret...). Without hesitation, Merry understands that he
has to help Sam and Frodo leave the Shire and instantly comes up with an escape
route.
191) When the Black Rider's horse jumps out at the hobbits, Frodo is actually
keeping it busy while the others get away and run to the ferry. Then he
follows. The Rider tries to cut him off, but he easily slips by once the others
are clear and call out to him.
192) Running to the ferry, Sam vaults and clears the fence as easily as Merry &
Pippin even though he's carrying three times the weight in gear!
193) As the hobbit ride the ferry, you can see the dock and lamp on the other
side of the river.
AT THE SIGN OF THE PRANCING PONY
194) There are two holes in the door at Bree, one for humans, one for hobbits.
As they go through the gate, Merry & Pippin whisper to each other… comments
about ale?
195) PJ's cameo in Bree, he burps in our face, and he's eating a carrot
196) When the hobbits first enter the Prancing Pony, Frodo looks over at Merry
who encouragingly nods at Frodo to go ahead and inquire about Gandalf.
197) As they enter the Prancing Pony, Merry and Pippin look like they're ready
to party while Sam looks suspiciously around and Frodo is nervous.
198) Sam is watching everyone around them from the moment they entered the
Pony. He even noticed 'that fellow' who'd been watching them since they
arrived.
199) Strider’s boots are muddy as he sits at the Prancing Pony just as
described in the book.
200) Aragorn (then Strider) is smoking his pipe, his eyes glow from the
embers.
201) At Bree there is a squinty-eyed man (southerner?) discussing the hobbits
with another man (Bill Ferny?)
202) Merry makes the most darling, affirmative "mmm!" in response to Pip asking
if it comes in pints. Merry's lips are immersed in the deep foam of the
ale.
203) The mugs the hobbits are holding are huge compared to their Hobbiton
crockery.
204) Frodo was resisting the ring's call to put it on (was taking a lot longer
than under the tree where Sam stopped him), so instead the ring used the
opportunity of his fall to go onto his finger and reveal itself (which the
Nazgul were immediately aware of).
205) When Pippin rushes over for his pint, the man standing next to him pats
him on the back in welcome! (first time other than Barliman you see someone
pleasant to the hobbits)
206) Someone must have asked Pippin if he knew any Baggins for him to point out
Frodo. Butterbur has a surprised look on his face since Frodo just introduced
himself as Mr. Underhill (recognized the name?).
207) Barliman's cat, seen as Frodo rushes to stop Pippin from blurting out his
name, might be a tiny allusion by P.J. to the ostler's cat in the song which
takes place at that point in the story in the book.
208) The flaming eye looks like it’s engulfing the shadowy figures of the
people as it approaches Frodo.
209) Just before the Hobbits burst into the room, Aragorn’s eyes flick toward
the door - he heard them coming.
210) Sam uses the name Longshanks when he challenges Strider
211) Pippin is holding a stool for a weapon when they burst in on Strider (HWF-
Hobbit Wrestling Federation), Merry's threateningly holding candelabra,
and Sam is bare-fisted… but still the most threatening!
212) There are chamber pots under the beds in the Prancing Pony.
213) Aragorn is wearing the Ring of Barahir on his left hand and a hand guard
on his right hand.
214) When Strider is with the hobbits at the Prancing Pony during the
Ringwraith's attack, he leaves on his cloak and holds his sword ready for
battle or a quick getaway. Frodo also has his coat on (not cloak) and is
sitting up with Strider while Sam, Merry and Pippin are sleeping.
215) Pippin smacks his lips as he sleeps. Still thinking of food
(midnightsies?).
216) Aragorn snarls slightly when he's telling the hobbits who the wraiths are
"They are the Nazgul..." He also snarls slightly when leading the hobbits in
the wild (just as they stop for second breakfast)
217) When Aragorn is leading the hobbits to Rivendell, it's raining in one
scene. In a close up, we see Aragorn pulling his coat closer around him
and then in the next scene we see a far away view of them walking. I can see
rain against the trees. There's snow about, too. It's cold out there!
218) Pippin's second breakfast comment comes from Bilbo's second breakfast in
The Hobbit and elevenses from A Long Expected Party.
219) Aragorn tosses apples to the hobbits when they can’t stop for second
breakfast. Even though he won’t let them stop, he still sympathizes enough to
supply them with food.
220) Pippin is looking around trying to figure out where that apple came from
(staggering ever so slightly)
221) Frodo steps in cold, mushy ground after repacking Bill. Not a pleasant
walk, fresher.
222) Sauron begins to speak to Saruman with the black speech, but changes to
the common tongue.
223) When Saruman is receiving instructions from Sauron through the palantir,
Sauron tells Saruman to build him an Army "worthy of Mordor," Saruman seems
tormented and disheveled afterwards.
224) When the trees are being torn down at Isengard, they groan and cry,
perhaps a clue as to what the Ents will sound like. (Hoom haroom )
A KNIFE IN THE DARK
225) When they arrive at Amon Sul, you can see Strider standing on the outcrop
from a distance.
226) Hobbits had never handled, let alone used, a sword before Aragorn gave
them their blades at Weathertop.
227) Pippin's face is usually so expressive, but he is absolutely stone faced
on Weathertop as he holds his new sword. All the others unsheathe their swords,
looking at them with various expressions of wonder and worry. But for
Pip, it seems to be the first time he really starts to understand just what
this adventure will demand of him. (Interestingly enough, Billy Boyd has fenced
competitively, so of them all he at least knew how to use a sword. He talks
about the difficulties of learning to fight like a hobbit when he already knew
somewhat about fencing to begin with. Elijah also had some previous
training in fencing.)
228) Frodo is again, the one who seems to understand more than the rest that
they will probably need the swords, Merry looks like a kid with a new toy, Sam
looks a wee bit confused, and Pippin, well, hey, he's Pippin. /g/
(Interestingly enough, Billy Boyd has fenced competitively, so of them all he
at least knew how to use a sword. He talks about the difficulties of learning
to fight like a hobbit when he already knew somewhat about fencing to begin
with.)
229) Only a hobbit would light a fire and cook a feast of food while hiding
from Black Riders
230) At Weathertop, Sam is eating out of a mini pot with a wooden spoon, the
same items he will use for herbs and stewed rabbit.
231) Pippin's face lights up and he nods enthusiastically when Merry tells
Frodo what's cooking.
232) Sam's got a plate of food ready for Frodo for when he wakes up, and is
still holding it and his own pot when they run over to look down on the wraiths
approaching Weathertop.
233) Frodo (Elijah) puts out the campfire with his bare foot!
234) With Strider gone, Frodo takes charge when the wraiths are about to
attack, draws his sword and gets the hobbits moving! "Go!" and they all run to
the top of Amon Sul.
235) Sam is not overwhelmed by the presence of the Black Riders at Weathertop.
He strikes at them first.
236) The Nazgul hold their swords in front of their faces when advancing on the
hobbits on Weathertop. It’s the same way Elendil held Narsil in the
prologue and the way Aragorn holds it when he fights the Uruk-hai towards the
end of the film. Probably PJ's way of showing they were all of the same race of
men.
237) When Frodo is on the ground trying to slide away from the wraiths, he's
stopped when he comes up against a fallen statue (the same type of statue that
is found elsewhere at Weathertop and at Parth Galen.)
238) Frodo resists the Wraith and the Ring when he pulls away as the Wraith
reaches for the ring. He's GOT to be experiences pressure from both. Very
tough hobbit!
239) Twice Aragorn/Strider physically jumps between Frodo and his
attackers. Here and when the cave troll attacks in Moria.
240) Sam runs right through Aragorn's fight with the Wraiths (ducking as one
swings its sword) to get to Frodo. Merry and Pippin also make their way
to Frodo.
241) The Morgul blade disintegrates and vanishes just as in the book.
242) There are white hands on the doors in Saruman's throne room worked into
the design of the doors.
243) At Isengard, the Orcs slipped in a comment to Saruman about the trees
being strong and having deep roots. The same orc is Saruman's assistant in at
least three scenes (he has a line of nasal-bridge rings down his face): in the
"we have work to do" scene, in the tree-ripping down scene, and in the Lurtz
birth scene--it's the same orc-dude in all three.
244) There are sort of baby 'cooing' noises in the background as Lurtz is
'born'.
245) After the battle of Weathertop and Frodo has been stabbed by the Black
Rider, they are found resting in a forested area. The stones behind them are
the trolls that Bilbo, Gandalf and the Dwarves turned to stone from The Hobbit
(the story Bilbo was telling the hobbit children at his party)
246) When lying on the ground by the stone trolls, Frodo seems to react when
Aragorn says to Pippin, "He’ll soon become a wraith like them." Frodo’s gasps
and his cries sound like the wraiths, and they seem to respond to his cries in
kind. "They're close." (Perhaps it's setting the poison to work
more.)
247) Merry helps Strider stand guard on lookout for the Wraiths holding a brand
of fire.
248) Sam runs into the dark to look for athelas to save Frodo when the wraiths
have just screeched and they are all so frightened. He is so brave and
dedicated.
249) Apparently an Elf can sneak up on a Ranger. Aragorn doesn't see
Arwen coming, and catches him off guard.
250) As we first see Arwen, the choir seems to sing the name "Tinuviel" in a
long drawn out way.
251) As Arwen approaches Frodo, he sees her as the wraiths see her (because
he’s becoming one of them as he fades from the poison of the morgul blade ).
She appears to him as she does in the Blessed Realm glowing and dressed in
white. Everyone else sees her as she appears in Middle Earth, dressed in grey.
Arwen and the Wraiths are the only thing Frodo seems to be able to see... he's
fading and falling into the Shadow World.
FLIGHT TO THE FORD
252) Arwen rides the same horse that Glorfindel did in the book… Asfaloth
253) When Arwen is leaving with Frodo, she leans forward and quietly says,
"Noro lim, Asfaloth." The horse snickers and shakes his head slightly in
response.
254) Aragorn looks anxiously as Arwen rides away, because it’s not just Frodo
that’s in danger… he’s sent his love off alone knowing the wraiths will do
their best to stop them.
255) Arwen rides Asfaloth full tilt cutting through the trees, and then she
calls to him when the Wraith reaches for Frodo and he redoubles his speed and
tears away!
256) Arwen baits the Black Riders to get them to enter the water.
257) When Arwen chants to the river and it rises up, there are figures of the
white horses in the foam crashing over the wraiths! Asfaloth is still in the
water, but doesn't get swept away- it doesn't even get wet.
258) Arwen had her father's blade from the Last Alliance. It does not
have a haft (the crossbar above the hilt)
259) Frodo collapses when the Black Riders are washed away. Does he
collapse because they're, basically, collapsed?
260) After crossing the ford, as Arwen lays Frodo on the river's edge, he's
gasping for breath and his eyes almost black. He's succumbing to the poison and
is fading. He stops breathing after struggling for the last few gasps of
breath.
261) Arwen's lines about "What grace is given me" are being sung in English in
the background during that scene.
WELCOME TO RIVENDELL
262) Fading Frodo sees the blurred archways passing above him when he’s being
carried into Rivendell.
263) At either side of Frodo's sick bed in Rivendell there are flowers or herbs
suspended in bundles; medications, cups and whatnot on the table; a vase of
pink roses; and the statue/headboard of Frodo’s sickbed has a shawl around her
arms.
264) When Frodo awakens in Rivendell, he's swimming in the bedclothes. They're
way too big for a hobbit.
265) Someone has put the ring on a chain around Frodo's neck (as in the
book)
266) Frodo's left hand looks transparent after his healing. He should also now
begin to have a slight aura of light about him like the Elves (technically this
is admitted by the crew of LOTR)
267) Frodo is surprisingly clear-headed after he wakes up. He immediately asks,
"What happened, Gandalf? Why didn't you meet us?"
268) Atop the tower of Orthanc, there are a couple of bowls of food that
Saruman had provided for "his guest".
269) The patterns on the floor of Isengard match the patterns on the top where
Gandalf's held captive.
270) The moth is fluttering in the background behind Saruman just as Gandalf is
about to step off the edge of the tower.
271) Gwaihir approaches Orthanc as quietly as the moth, then screeches in
defiance just before catching Gandalf!
272) You can see the tiny image of Saruman standing on top of Orthanc as
Gandalf flies away.
273) There's not noticeable way of accessing the top of Orthanc (i.e. trap
door, staircase).
274) Gwaihir flies in the dark (nearing sunrise) to help Gandalf. Eagles don't
normally fly at night. Then as the sun rises, it's on his left (heading
south to Edoras).
275) The embroidery on Elrond’s clothing is in the same style as the
architecture of Rivendell.
276) There are Celtic-like knots in Elrond's hair
277) The peacock, symbolic of immortality and incorruptibility, seems to be a
recurring motif. The quiver that Legolas is given has a peacock embossed on it.
Some of the swirly Rivendell architecture is reminiscent of the peacock's tail
feathers. Elrond's chair at the council has that fan-tail shape as well. A
white peacock is briefly visible as Legolas runs down the stairs (and it can be
seen in one of the stills that was not in the movie). Side note: I thought the
peacock thing was weird -- to me they symbolize vanity. However, I recently
found out they also are symbolic of incorruptibility and eternal life. So it's
an appropriate symbol for the Elves.
MANY MEETINGS
278) When we see Bilbo in Rivendell, not only is the hair on his head white,
the hair on his feet is too!
279) Bilbo's clothing is still in the style of the Shire. However, the material
of his waistcoat is now "elvish" silky shantung-like stuff. He wore a red
vest when he found the ring and during his party.
280) The bench that Bilbo sat on was appropriately too large for him.
281) When Frodo looks at the Red Book, he says "This is wonderful" because he’s
never seen it before - unlike in the book.
282) Gandalf's name appears in Bilbo's book (across from the drawing of the
Shire)
283) Frodo is still pale and washed-out looking when he's reunited with his
friends and Bilbo.
284) As Sam is packing in Rivendell, queries "what have I forgotten"
(referencing rope from books)
285) Frodo doesn't realize he can go home until Sam says they've "done what
they set out to do," and now they can go "off 'ome."
286) In the beginning, Frodo is just as Gandalf described him to Butterbur in
the book - a perky chap with red cheeks (etc). But after Weathertop, he
is pale, with the beginnings of the "elf-glow".
287) Gandalf walks a little stiffly and with an aged gait when talking with
Elrond and throughout the film (Can’t wait to see how Gandalf the White carries
himself).
288) The quill pens in the various places match their surroundings. Black in
Orthanc, mixed white and "stripey" in Rivendell, Barliman Butterbur's quill is
frayed at the edges, stripey feathers in Minas Tirith.
289) One of the Rivendell buildings (maybe the Hall of Fire ?) has a dragon
motif. There is a dragon head front and along the top of the roofline it looks
like vertebrae. Another building has a bird head.
290) In Rivendell after Elrond says, "The Ring cannot stay here," Gandalf turns
away, despondently gazing into the distance from a balcony. Then his expression
changes slightly, he stares harder then looks almost optimistic.
291) The scene cuts to the arrival of Boromir, Legolas and Gimli. Gandalf takes
comfort from noting their arrival.
292) Boromir’s horse rides up seeming heavy, weighted by it rider and gear
(medallions, bridle, etc). Legolas’ horse trots up very light and quick.
293) Boromir wears chain mail (and this makes one think about Boromir's
background - the man wears a mail shirt, and a heavy leather vest, and carries
a shield. Think he's been through a lot?)
294) Elrond and Gandalf don’t consider hobbits as a possible race to look to
for help (only men and Dwarves).
295) Rivendell is very open with leaves strewn about and the sound of birds
throughout the rooms.
ONLY A BROKEN HEIRLOOM
296) Aragorn is drawn to Narsil even in solitude (when he's reading).
297) Boromir is examining the shards of Narsil when he nicks himself. The line,
"it's still sharp," was wasted on most of the audience. (Sean Bean played
Richard Sharpe in the "Sharpe's Rifles" series)
298) Boromir drops Narsil and Aragorn picks it up. It's probably the first time
Aragorn's touched it (in the book, he carries it with him).
299) When Boromir walks away from Aragorn and Narsil, he looks like he's
putting his cut finger in his mouth.
300) Narsil is broken into five shards. Including the hilt, there are a
total of six pieces.
301) The statue bearing the Narsil shards has on its 'pin' the White Tree.
302) The shield holding the shards of Narsil is like the one used by the Elves
at the Last Alliance (probably from that battle).
303) There are little pearly beads embroidered on Arwen's white dress - the one
she's wearing in the love scene w/Aragorn. Galadriel has the same
beadwork on her dress.
304) The beautiful detail in the floor tiles, wood work, furniture,
architecture in Rivendell is earthy and natural
305) The intricate braiding of Gimli's beard: I've always been partial to all
things Dwarven (at least where fantasy novels are concerned), and the beard
reflected a concern and care for the culture of the race as reflected in
Tolkien's work.
306) Gimli's helmet and armor has a very similar design to the architecture of
Moria (the whole dwarf theme)
THE COUNCIL OF ELROND
307) The shrine holding the shards of Narsil is up behind Aragorn during the
Council of Elrond.
308) There are twenty-two members at the Council.
309) Aragorn and Legolas are the only Fellowship members at the Council not
wearing traveling clothes.
310) The ring has a low-decibel ringing sound when Frodo's places it on the
pedestal at Elrond's Council (as it did at Bag End)
311) Frodo looks relieved after placing the ring on the pedestal at the
Council...freely giving it up and believing he's done his part and can now go
home.
312) Aragorn can’t sit quietly in a chair… he’s sprawled out and fidgety! (A
man of action!)
313) When Boromir says, "...Gondor needs no king." and sits down, the men on
either side of him look sternly straight ahead as if not to acknowledge
Aragorn. However, the men between Legolas and the dwarfs openly gape at Aragorn
when his identity is revealed. Aragorn looks down as if in submission to
their rejection.
314) The ring hisses when Elrond says, "The ring must be destroyed."
315) Only Frodo can hear the ring at the Council as soon as it is threatened by
what Elrond says.
316) The looks that pass between Elrond and Gandalf through the whole council
reflect reactions to the previous conversations. Boromir proving Elrond’s
opinion of men, while Aragorn supports Gandalf’s.
317) Gimli grabs the axe of the dwarf sitting next to him to try and destroy
the ring.
318) When Gimli strikes the Ring with the axe, Aragorn throws his arm up over
his face, as if he's trying to shield himself.
319) There’s already a connection between Frodo and the ring. He freely gives
it up at the council, but when Gimli attacks it… Frodo’s been affected, too
(much to his distress)
320) Frodo and Sam listen to Boromir's description of Mordor. Information
they'll end up relying on quite heavily.
321) The Ring calls out in Black Speech at the Council: "Ash nazg durbatulûk,
ash nazg gimbatul, ash nazg thrakatulûk, agh burzum-ishi krimpatul" as it is
taking control and stirring the argument and dissention among the council
members.
322) Frodo, Aragorn, Elrond, Erestor and the elf seated with them are the only
ones who don't participate (or are incited) in the argument by the ring in the
shouting match at the Council.
323) Only time the ring reflects something other than its surroundings is
during the Council of Elrond when everyone is arguing and flames consume the
Council.
324) Legolas is holding back his blonde elf companions after Gimli insults him
during the Council of Elrond argument.
325) Figwit can speak! Well, argue anyway. Ok, so we can’t hear him. But he’s
one of the first to jump to his feet when the Council erupts in argument, and a
moment later we see him arguing vehemently with someone. Methinks he must be
uttering words of incredible wisdom and insight. Wish he wasn’t such a hothead,
though.
326) Gandalf's has a look of anxiety when Frodo offers to take the ring to
Mordor, and Aragorn looks surprised (knowing what Frodo's been through
already)
327) Aragorn's decision to join the Fellowship marks the end of his
self-imposed exile.
328) When the Fellowship is formed at the end of it's breaking apart at Parth
Galen, Aragorn gets down on one knee before Frodo. And not just to talk to a
short person, but as a gesture of honor. The first time he does it is at the
council of Elrond to swear his protection. The final time is to confirm that
promise before he sends him away. It's a wonderful example of the humility with
which Aragorn chooses to come into his kingdom.
329) Gandalf looks over at Elrond and winks when Aragorn says he'll go with
Frodo. This was a reference to Elrond's disparaging comments about Aragorn and
men in general in the scene with Gandalf before the council.
330) When Gandalf approaches Frodo saying he'll help him bear this burden, the
two Elves nearest Frodo slightly bow in courtesy of Gandalf and back away.
331) Legolas shoots a disapproving look when Gimli joins the Fellowship.
332) Boromir's delivery of his final words, as he walks over to join the others
who've volunteered to accompany Frodo. When he says "If this is indeed the will
of the Council" there's a sardonic look on his face, and his voice
matches that "indeed"! and he is looking at the Council at large -
clearly he doesn't agree with the decision to destroy the Ring. He then he
drops his gaze to look directly at Frodo and says, in a gentler tone of voice
and with complete sincerity, "then Gondor will see it done."
333) As the fellowship is declared by Elrond, Sam and Boromir are the only two
who don't look very happy about it.
334) Sting and Narsil are the only weapons referred to by name.
THE RING GOES SOUTH
335) At Rivendell, while Bilbo is with Frodo, giving him Sting and the mithril
coat, there is a brief shot of Legolas coming down some stairs to meet the
other members of the Fellowship - there is Bill the pony, Sam is adjusting the
saddle, while Merry and Pip are to his left, and Boromir is standing on the
right!
336) There's a gathering of Elves/men on the balcony watching the Fellowship as
it leaves Rivendell (mentioned in book).
337) Aragorn doesn't carry his bow and arrow till they leave Rivendell. The
fletching of Aragorn’s arrows looks black
338) Legolas carries his knives in sheaths on his back (behind his shoulder
blades instead of at his waist). That way he can grab them with the same motion
he uses for drawing arrows.
339) Sam is cooking for Frodo and serving him as he would have at Bag End and
did at Weathertop.
340) Boromir is drawn to the halflings: this is shown when he is training Merry
and Pippin and wrestling with them on the ground. It makes his sacrifice for
them at the end that much stronger. This is also demonstrated on the stair of
Khazad-dum, and when he asks Aragorn to allow them time to mourn after the
events of Moria.
341) Merry tosses his apple to Aragorn when ready to swordplay with
Boromir.
342) Uncharacteristically, Strider puts his sword aside while watching Boromir
teach Merry and Pippin to sword fight.
343) During the sword practice scene with Boromir and the young hobbits,
Boromir is speaking out numbers as he performs the various manuveours. These
numbers correspond to the positions used in fencing, and which are used in
modern fencing practice.
344) Boromir's love for the halflings: this is shown when he is training Merry
and Pippin and wrestling with them on the ground. It makes his sacrifice for
them at the end that much stronger. This is also demonstrated when he asks
Aragorn to allow them time to mourn after the events of Moria.
345) The surprised look on Pippin's face when Boromir's sword grazes his
hand.... then they yell "for the Shire!" they attack (just at Frodo does in
Moria in the book)
346) During Merry & Pippin's sword lesson, it's the only time you see Aragorn,
Boromir and Frodo laughing together.
347) Gandalf's hair is tied back while resting on the rocks while Gimli's is
laid loose.
348) The first thing Boromir thinks of when the crebain flies towards them is
making sure Merry and Pippin are hidden. Aragorn cries out to Sam and Frodo
"take cover!"
349) Other than Frodo, the ring only calls to the men of the Fellowship. The
hobbits, Legolas, Gimli nor Gandalf show any interest in it. Gandalf is exposed
to it, but never is drawn to take it.
350) Boromir and Aragorn are carrying the hobbits through the snows of
Caradhras (as in the book)
351) On the Redhorn Pass - Legolas trots lightly upon the snow's surface while
the rest of the Fellowship are slogging through deep snow.
352) When the Fellowship is climbing up the Misty Mountains, and they hear
Saruman's voice, Saruman is speaking in Quenya, while Gandalf is speaking in
Sindarin.
353) Legolas reaches into the snow and pulls Gimli out of the drift where he's
buried.
354) Aragorn's arm shoots up out of the snow, then he uncovers Frodo and Sam.
THE WATCHER IN THE WATER
355) The wolves are howling from across the lake as the Fellowship tries to
enter Moria.
356) The ithildin image on the doors of Moria is Tolkien’s own illustration for
the book (also his work seen in Saruman’s book)
357) At the gate of Moria, Gandalf looked up... then we see the full moon... If
you know something about astronomy, you may notice that the south pole of the
moon was up, while the north pole was down, which proves that the movie was
indeed shot in the southern hemisphere.
358) The holly trees are present on ether side of the doors of Moria.
359) The sleeves under Gandalf's cloak can be pulled down to cover his hands
(has thumb holes).
360) Frodo uses 'Strider' and 'Aragorn' interchangeably, while Sam calls him
Strider and Merry calls him Aragorn.
361) Legolas is always standing at attention (on alert) with his bow in hand.
He never freakin' blinks! I think I have caught him blinking twice. That is
awesome for a keen-eyed Elf!
362) The Wood Elf is standing under the tree as Gandalf tries to decipher the
password.
363) Gandalf places a crystal from his pouch on the top of his staff and blows
on it to light the way
364) Legolas studies the arrowheads to determine which enemy fought in the
mines.
365) The Watcher in the Water music resembles old Twenty Thousand Leagues Under
the Sea movie music
366) The Watcher grabs Frodo first by the right leg then by the left leg, then
later the cave troll does the same thing. Then Frodo has to "RUN". That's gotta
hurt!
367) Frodo has drawn Sting as he's being dragged to the water by the watcher...
but Sam runs up and frees him from its grip.
368) Legolas shoots the tentacle that has covered Frodo's face (dangerously
close to hitting Frodo! Great shot, Legolas!)
369) When Frodo drops into Boromir's arms after he falls from the Watcher's
grasp, Boromir yells "LEGOLAS!!" and then Gandalf yells "INTO THE MINES!" and
then Aragorn yells "INTO THE CAVE!!" in the split second before Legolas shoots
the Watcher in the eye (posted because many were confused with this).
370) Frodo is not only caught by Boromir from the Watcher, but also when he and
Aragorn have been trapped on the staircase and they finally jump off - Boromir
catches Frodo then as well. Seems to me that Boromir does a little more
Ring-bearer catching than is good for him.
371) Legolas and Boromir help Frodo into the mines after escaping the Watcher
in the Water as Strider ushers the other hobbits in front of him.
A JOURNEY IN THE DARK
372) When Pippin is afraid, he holds hands with Merry. I've seen this twice:
When he slips on the stairs when they first enter Moria, and when he jumps out
of hiding at Amon Hen.
373) Gollum actually makes the gollum sound as he leaps out of the camera's
sight in Moria... he says "gollum" twice throughout the whole movie.
374) The men seem to stick together, as do the hobbits, which leaves Gimli and
Legolas alone to form a unique bond.
375) As dirty and scroungy as everyone else gets on the long journey, Legolas
is always pristine
376) Gimli chants or prays in dwarvish while kneeling at Balin's tomb
(praying?)
377) The Dwarf journal Gandalf reads from at the tomb is hacked, cut and has
blood stains and leafs or pages falling out of it just as described in the
book. It has writing in both Dwarvish and Elvish runes, just as in the
book.
378) There is a "G" rune on Gandalf's staff. You can see it when Pippin is
holding it in Moria by the well.
379) Boromir and Merry are the supportive ones in the film. Merry pats Gimli on
the shoulder at Parth Galen, looks at Pippin/Sam when despondent; Boromir
places his hand on Gimli’s shoulder at Balin’s tomb and supports him after
escaping Moria.
380) When Pippin is holding Gandalf's hat in Moria as he's reading the dwarf
diary, you can see a repair stitching on it near Pippin's fingers.
381) During the noise of the skeleton falling in the well, everyone is looking
around except Merry, who's looking over to Pippin (he feels for his
friend).
382) The exasperated sigh that Boromir lets out after the noise of Pippin's
mistake in Moria ends (and Aragorn's annoyed snort)
383) If you look at the two arrows that hit the door to Balin's Tomb in Moria,
you'll notice that they are fletched with hair...dwarf-hair I'm assuming, since
it doesn’t appear to be the same color and/or texture as orc hair.
384) Boromir is very skilled with his sword (twirls it with his hands before
battle in Moria and when instructing Merry & Pippin)
385) Gandalf loses his hat when he throws it down before battling the orcs and
cave troll in Moria. It's the last we see of it.
386) Pippin is the first to charge the orcs.
387) When the hobbits draw their swords, Sam looks nervously at Frodo… bracing
himself.
388) "Sting" glows when orcs are near, but NOT when they are in plain view
(like during the Moria fight), probably because, hey, if you're stabbing an
orc, you don't need no smart-alecky reminder from your sword that orcs are
nearby.
389) During the first battle in Moria - there is no music, for the whole first
half of the battle.
390) True to the book, Sam was the first of the halflings to slay an orc, "A
sturdy thrust with his barrow blade."
391) During the battle in Moria, Sam reverts to a weapon he can relate to...
his cooking pan. He uses both his sword and pan like Gandalf uses is sword and
staff.
392) The cave-troll wildly swings his hammer and kills two of the orcs on his
"team"--one of whom is the one who leads him on his chain.
393) Just as Gimli is about to be bludgeoned by the Cave Troll, Legolas shoots
TWO arrows at the same time from his bow and saves Gimli (doubleshot!)
394) Merry and Pippin threw stones at the cave troll in Moria and at the
Uruk-hai at Parth Galen.
395) You can see where the ring has fallen out of Frodo's shirt as he tries to
revive Aragorn.
396) Frodo stabs the Cave Troll at least twice... he's not a passive victim in
that fight.
397) Can see the arrow sticking out of the top back of the cave troll’s head
where Legolas has shot him through the mouth (there was a lot of debate on
this).
398) The hall from which they enter the Chamber of Mazarbul is not the same one
which they exit into. It appears, from the direction of the shaft of light,
that they are at right angles to one another. They exit through a huge
hole in the wall. The shaft of light is revealed when they ran out.
399) The Orcs in the books are never fully described - are they hairy or scaly
or both? Jackson's Orcs are individually very different, which gives the viewer
a lot of latitude in deciding what an Orc looks like.
THE BRIDGE OF KHAZAD-DUM
400) When running from the orcs in Khazad-dum, Frodo’s shirt is still open from
exposing the mithril shirt! (good detail)
401) Running out of the Chamber of Mazarbul, Sam keeps his hand on Frodo’s
back.
402) You can hear the words "Khazad ai-menu" during the dwarvish chanting in
Moria in the movie
403) Right before the shot of the Orcs crawling down the ceiling in Moria,
Legolas looks upwards towards the ceiling. I just thought it was interesting to
see that someone in the fellowship acknowledged them
404) When the Orcs run away from the Balrog., Gimli looks pleased and amused,
as if his "prowess" had scared them all away.
405) When Gandalf says, "A Balrog...a demon of the ancient world..." Legolas is
the only member of the company who understands(being the only other immortal
and knowing Elvish history, he knows exactly what Gandalf is talking
about).
406) The Orcs in Moria have large eyes compared to the orcs that Saruman uses.
The reason the Moria orcs have larger eyes than the Isengard Orcs is that they
live in the dark, and evolved that way--also part of the reason why they cannot
stand the light as well.
407) When running through the mines away from the Balrog, while everyone else
appears to be running at full speed, Legolas looks like he's jogging. This is
true in other places where they are forced to run away.
408) When they are running down the stairs in Moria just before the collapsing
bridge/stairway, instead of going around the corner from one flight to the
other like everyone else, Legolas jumps over the side to the steps below,
saving himself from running down four or five steps and Gimli also jumps from
lower down.
409) Legolas is so sure-footed. As he hops up on the rock to watch the crebain,
he's just as graceful as he always is. When he jumps off his horse in
Rivendell, when he jumps the stairs in Khazad-dum... he land firmly and never
waivers. Very cat-like.
410) None of Legolas' targets move around much once they're hit. They just
drop!
411) In Khazad-dum, Legolas shoots an arrow with so much force it sails across
a wide abyss, pierces through an orcs skull and embeds in the stone pillar.
412) The Fellowship jumped (or were tossed) from the collapsing stairs in this
order: Legolas; Gandalf; Boromir w/M&P; Sam; Gimli; Aragorn; then Frodo.
413) Arguably the two most important Fellowship members are the ones stranded
on the stairs after Gimli jumps (Aragorn and Frodo).
414) Gimli worried about his beard... a very dwarvish thing.
415) When the stairs are collapsing, Aragorn makes certain Frodo is safe before
he throws himself up higher on the steps.
416) If the stairs in Moria had fallen the other way, they'd have been cut
off.
417) The Fellowship crossed the Bridge of Khazad-dum in this order: Aragorn;
Boromir; Frodo; Pippin; Merry; Sam; Gimli; Legolas; Gandalf. Merry passes
Pippin after getting across and run to climb the stairs.
418) Gandalf gets stronger and straighter as he confronts the Balrog and says
who he is and commands the Balrog. The light around him gets bigger and
brighter.
419) When fighting the Balrog, Gandalf always glows white when receiving or
giving blows.
420) We're watching Gandalf's battle with the Balrog from Frodo's perspective;
from over his shoulder.
421) Aragorn lingers after Gandalf falls, narrowly dodging arrows from the Orcs
as Boromir routs everyone to escape from Moria after Gandalf has fallen.
422) You know Gandalf can hear Frodo’s cries as he’s falling.
423) It's Boromir who routs everyone after Gandalf has fallen.
424) Aragorn is so stunned he lingers and narrowly dodges an arrow shot at his
head.
425) When the Fellowship escapes Moria, they're struck with the glaring, eye
piercing brightness of the day.
426) The order of the Fellowship when running from Moria onto the rocks:
Pippin; Sam; Merry; Legolas; Gimli; Frodo; Boromir; Aragorn. Sam passes Pippin
and sits on the rocks ahead of them
427) When they all come out of Moria, watch Gimli. Boromir has a struggle on
his hands as he holds Gimli back because he wants to run back into Moria for
Gandalf. You can see Gimli’s legs trying to run away from Boromir.
428) Merry watches Sam while holding Pippin after escaping Moria. He's
always empathizing with others in distress.
429) A common thread in the storyline - that one character falters, and another
pulls him through
430) Legolas has three arrows (perhaps four) in his quiver when the Fellowship
exits Moria and enters the woods of Lothlorien. The number remains the same as
they entered Moria.
LOTHLORIEN
431) The brief look of contentment and anticipation flashes across Aragorn's
face as he looks toward Lorien.
432) The trees of Lorien seem to clatter and ring when Legolas and Aragorn
enter the wood as if to welcome them (the traveler they know and the Wood
Elf).
433) The arrowheads of the Lorien Elves seem to be stylized versions of leaves
like the ones seen to the side of Galadriel and Celeborn as they descend to
greet the Fellowship.
434) The Lorien bows are longer than Legolas' Mirkwood bow.
435) Lothlorien Elves have white feathers for their fletching and Legolas
(Mirkwood Elves have brown.) The Uruk-hai also has fletching that looks
like hair (like the Moria Orcs).
436) Frodo uses his telepathy for the first time with Galadriel (unknowingly
using the power of the ring?) He is almost knocked over when he first receives
the telepathy as he enters Lorien. He receives telepathic voice from Sauron
(but only while wearing the ring and from the ring itself).
437) When the Fellowship is being led up the stairs to the flet where they
await Celeborn and Galadriel, if you look up to the next very large flet, it
looks like they're sitting off to the left as an attendant crosses the floor at
the top of the stair and approaches them.
438) Galadriel was as tall as Celeborn, like in the book; 'the Lady no less
tall than the Lord'. Amazing detail!
439) The floor of the platform where the Fellowship meet Galadriel is decorated
with the images of giant mallorn leaves
440) When Galadriel is addressing the Fellowship, she looks at Boromir and
knows he'll fail, but she looks at Sam (who doesn't look away) and she seems to
know he will be true and the hope of the quest. "Yet hope remains as long as
the company is true..." she says as she quietly smiles.
441) The sparkles in Galadriel’s eyes while all of the others have one, sharp
light reflection. They look like stars or daggers.
442) In Lothlorien there are heavily laden plates of food behind Boromir when
he starts talking about Gondor.
443) When Boromir is in Lorien, he says that she (Galadriel) spoke of hope, but
he can't see it. Sitting next to him, listening, is Aragorn, also known as
Estel. The translation of Estel is hope. According to the book Aragorn's mother
named him "Hope", meaning the hope of his people.
444) Aragorn’s look of disbelief when Boromir says he’ll take no rest in
Lothlorien. Aragorn obviously can’t fathom not being comforted in
Lothlorien.
445) When Boromir starts talking about the White Tower of Ecthelion, he raises
his head and looks off into the distance as if seeing it. Behind him, we see
Aragorn raise his head with almost a startled expression and look off at
exactly the same angle, as if seeing the same thing. Both hold these positions
until Boromir turns back to look at Aragorn. It's a beautiful shot.
446) When Boromir says his line about someday, the trumpets of the White City
calling home the Lords of Gondor (implying him and Aragorn), an incredible look
of conflict crosses Aragorn’s face. He had been looking sympathetic, but when
Boromir delivers that line, Aragorn suddenly seems consumed by an internal
conflict: pursue the mission of the Quest, or follow Boromir to his (Aragorn’s
ancestral city?)
447) Most of the statues in the Elven realms look female or androgynous. The
statues Galadriel passes as she walks down the stairs toward her mirror appear
to be statues of herself.
448) It's clear in the vision of the Shire that Frodo sees in Galadriel's
mirror that there are two hobbits in the line that are head and shoulders
bigger than the others, and their hair matches Merry and Pippin. Has to be the
boys after the Ent draughts.
449) The door to the Hobbiton mill is (human) rectangular rather than (hobbit)
circular. This would tie in with Ted Sandyman's love of technology and
rejection of hobbit ways.
450) There is smoke rising from Galadriel's mirror after Frodo falls away from
it... just like in the book
451) When Galadriel converts to what she would be as a dark lord, it's the
first time Frodo truly realizes the power of the ring
452) Galadriel and Gandalf both grow and cause the light to darken and blows
wind towards Frodo and Bilbo (respectively) when they're riled.
453) When Galadriel "transforms" she appears the same as when the Fellowship
first meet her during the line "...not dark but beautiful". During the next
line "....and terrible as the dawn...." she transforms fully into her "wraith
form" and her voice is overlayed with another. She goes on to say
".....treacherous as the sea......", her sleeves are torn and tattered as if
she survived a shipwreck (or like the Wraiths' and Sauron's clothes). And
during the same time her "Wraithform" wears a plated corselet.
454) Galadriel's look of relief and resignation as she says "and remain
Galadriel.” It ever so slightly lingers as she turns to Frodo and her
face becomes stern when she says, “You are a ringbearer, Frodo…” At that
moment, he seems condemned.
455) Frodo instinctively knows he can trust Galadriel and Aragorn to withstand
the ring's influence and he doesn't hide the ring from them when they're
tempted. He knows he can't trust Boromir (asks to borrow the ring) or Bilbo and
keeps it hidden from them
456) Frodo communicates through thought/telepathy with Galadriel. His
power and perception is growing.
457) Not only did I notice the grey elvish cloaks they wore when departing
Lorien, but I liked the Elvish leaf clasp that held them together! Nice
attention to detail.
458) The only scene where we see Galadriel wearing Nenya (besides the prologue)
is when she is waving good-bye to the Fellowship
459) Saruman is talking to Lurtz in front of the palantir (is Sauron watching?)
THE GREAT RIVER
460) Sam's disgusted glance back towards Strider when in the boats are leaving
Lorien (he's NOT happy about being in a boat) and his continued look of
irritation while sailing on the River Anduin.
461) They keep the boats in the center of the river where the current is
stongest, their farthest from shore, and there are fewer obstacles.
(Wait! Is that a log drifting behind them?)
462) The Uruk-hai have the "White Hand" of Saruman painted on their faces.
463) You see Legolas then staring at his left and Lurtz at his right, it seems
as if both of them are looking at each other: as two mirrors of the same
picture, two extremes: the Elf, and the perfected corruption of the Elf.
464) As they pass the Argonath, you can see where the stone for the great
statues was quarried-- it looks like gigantic steps leading down to the river
Narsil is in the hand of Elendil's figure at the Argonath (in the book, they're
holding axes)
465) There’s a bird's nest in the right eye of the last king we see at the
Argonath (complete with baby birds)
PARTH GALEN and AMON HEN
466) When the Fellowship beaches their boats at Amon Hen, Boromir shivers. The
call of the Ring, or a premonition of his place of death?
467) Merry pats Gimli on the back/shoulder as he returns and sees that Gimli's
riled about something. (bet that happened a lot!) Merry's always so
supportive of the others.
468) The statue at Weathertop is almost identical to the one that overlooks
Boromir fighting at Amon Hen, only the one at Weathertop's hands are clasped
together and the one at Amon Hen has it's hand open and slightly spread apart
(receiving & giving?).
469) All the statues erected in the realm of Gondor are male.
470) Someone read the Atlas of Middle Earth. At Amon Hen (vestiges of an
ancient, lost civilization), you can clearly see Tol Brandir.
471) Frodo sees a vision of the army masses of Mordor and he hears black speech
and not the common tongue Sauron spoke in Bree.
472) When Aragorn finds Frodo at Amon Hen, he’s anxious and tense wondering
where the ring is - which makes Frodo back away. But when Frodo asks him, “Can
you protect me from yourself?” Aragorn stops in his tracks, and the look on his
face is amazing - suddenly deeply introspective. At that moment, he’s not sure.
This is the moment of the test that he has been fearing for so long, and he
wasn’t expecting it to come right then. But once he starts walking to Frodo
again, his face looks peaceful--he passes the test. Then the anguish in
Aragorn's face when he rejects the ring and knows Frodo has to leave.
473) The Ring calls out to Aragorn upon Amon Hen and uses his kingly name:
"Aragorn... Elessar..."
474) When Aragorn tells Frodo to run... the corner of Frodo's cloak lifts and
curls away as he runs off from the Uruk-hai (does the same thing when falling
on the steps in Khazad-dum). (Nothing of significance, just a lot of us thinks
it's very cool!)
475) Aragorn yells "Elendil!!" when he jumps from the Seat of Seeing at Amon
Hen.
476) There are two orcs running at Aragorn when Legolas tells Aragorn to go,
steps in between Aragorn and the orcs and fires. One orc is right behind the
other orc, and the arrow goes through both of them! Then he stabs an orc
with his arrow, then fires it, then fires his other arrows so quickly that no
one can get within ten feet of him. Excellent!
477) Legolas has so much control over the force of his shots. He could easily
have shot right through the orc Aragorn was struggling with at Amon Hen.
478) Merry & Pippin hide under a tree at Parth Galen as they did in the
Shire.
479) The grey Elven-cloaks do change colour - they're grey on the river, but
when Merry and Pippin are hiding from the orcs, they're green. Clever, eh?
480) Part of the reason Pippin gets so upset when Merry tells him Frodo is
leaving is because Pippin had just been listening to Gimli describe what it
would be like to walk to Mordor (festering marshlands, etc.) Merry was off
gathering wood and didn't hear. Sam was listening, too...and he didn't look to
happy about it. Sam also heard Boromir's description at the Council.
481) Boromir comes out of nowhere to save Merry & Pippin. Had he been off
wandering since his confrontation with Frodo? He didn't have his shield
(left at the camp). Maybe it would have helped save his life if he'd had
it.
482) Boromir is the only one who calls the hobbits "Little Ones" (although,
Frodo refers to hobbits as "Little People" in the title page of Bilbo & his
book). What at first seems a very patronizing expression is clearly an
endearment by the end. Boromir is also the only one to tussle hobbit hair as
one would do a child.
483) Lurtz holds his arrow from inside the string instead of outside (holds it
backwards)
484) As Boromir is overcome protecting the hobbits, there is a statue (it’s the
same fashion as the statues at Weathertop) overlooking the Son of Gondor as
he's falling. It seems as if he's being overlooked by a forefather.
485) Boromir's horn split (cloven in two)
486) Merry and Pippin are throwing rocks at the Uruk-hai while Boromir is
fighting. You can especially see them after he's taken the first and second
arrows. They fought the same way in Moria throwing rocks at the troll. But when
Boromir and Frodo fell, they grabbed their daggers and attacked. Part of hobbit
battle tactics. Formidable when aroused. The expression on the two
hobbits' faces as they tried to charge these towering Uruk-hai showed precisely
how much their doomed friend meant to them.
487) After Boromir gets hit by the second arrow from Lurtz's bow, he turns to
Merry and Pippin and Merry extends his hand towards Boromir, reaching out for
him for a brief moment, until the next Uruk-hai happens along and takes
Boromir's attention and his sword.
488) When Boromir is facing Lurtz, waiting for that final arrow... most people
would close their eyes. Boromir is in pain and despair, yet he's going to face
his death.
489) Boromir is mortally wounded with three arrows in his chest (facing his
foes in battle. Isildur's mortally wounded with three arrows in the back
(fleeing from foes?))
490) Aragorn drives his knife completely through Lurtz’s leg. You can see it
sticking through the back of his leg.
491) Aragorn deflects his own knife with his sword when Lurtz pulls it out of
his leg and throws it at him.
492) Legolas's face when Boromir's dying. He looks just devastated! He's
obviously listening to what's being said and understanding everything.
493) Aragorn knows exactly what to say to Boromir to ease his fears. His pledge
not to let the White City fall, or for their people to fail was also a pledge
to himself to follow his destiny.
494) Boromir’s death was not in vain… he saved the hobbits from the first
onslaught of orcs and guided Aragorn to claim his birthright. He bestowed
the kingship on Aragorn with his dying words. "My Captain, My King." Aragorn
kissing Boromir's forehead references the book, as in the following quote from
ttt, journey to the crossroads: "He embraced the hobbits then, after the manner
of his people, stooping, and placing his hands upon their shoulders, and
kissing their foreheads." This makes it seem like a cultural thing specific to
Gondor and further illustrates the common background between Aragorn and
Boromir.
495) Aragorn symbolizing acceptance as he straps on Boromir's bracers. It also
means he's representing Boromir in battle.
496) After fight scenes in Moria and Amon Hen, the Fellowship have black hands
and smudges of black on their faces. Orc blood is black
THE BREAKING OF THE FELLOWSHIP
497) In Moria Gandalf says "All we have to decide is what to do with the time
that is given to us," but when Frodo is alone on the Anduin remembering Gandalf
says, "All you have to decide is what to do with the time given to you."
498) Sam's pack is already in the boat Frodo takes across the river.
499) You can see the form of Frodo's boat moving across the light above Sam as
he sinks in the river.
500) Sam holds the oar wrong when he and Frodo cross the river.
501) Sam and Frodo don’t take everything packed in the boat as they climb the
eastern shore
502) Sam has somehow gotten his Elven brooch pinned on clumsily upside-down by
the end of the movie.
503) The only time Legolas comes close to smiling is right at the end, when
Gimli looks at him and shouts "YES!" and they run after Aragorn.
Legolas doesn't smile until Gimli has turned away and started off.
504) Aragorn only says Merry and Pippin's names once... "We will not abandon
Merry and Pippin to torment and death."
505) It is not common to see the chain around Frodo's neck. Only on occasion,
and they are specific to the action of the film. We see it in the final scene,
as Frodo and Sam overlook the East. Nice. Reminds us of the ring in the final
moment.
INCREDIBLE DETAILS THAT JUST NEED TO BE MENTIONED
506) Each culture has its own design theme. Hobbit buildings and artifacts have
a rustic, English Arts & Crafts influenced design. Bag End is probably the best
example of this. Elvish buildings and artifacts have a more sophisticated
design, very much influenced by Art Nouveau. You can see this in just about
everything in Rivendell. Saruman's study and throne room (for lack of a better
term) are very ornamental and Gothic. The Orcs have a very crude design ethic
that places raw function over form. (Just like the bad guys in those movies
where the future is very dark and grim.) Rohirrim artifacts (helmets, spears,
etc.) have a very Anglo-Saxon look to them; their buildings seem to be
influenced by Gothic and Viking designs. I haven't seen enough of Gondor to get
a good feel for the design theme for that culture.
507) Gandalf held drinks five times: With Frodo at the table at Bag End
discussing the ring; at Bilbo's party watching Merry and Pippin; at in the
library at Minas Tirith; at Isengard with Saruman; he never held a cup at Bag
End with Bilbo, but there was one in front of him on the table.
508) Gandalf smokes nine times: In cart with Frodo; on stoop w/Bilbo; Bilbo's
party; waiting for Frodo after Bilbo leaves; in the library at Minas Tirith;
with Frodo at the table in Bag End discussing ring; in Rivendell waiting for
Frodo's to reawaken; resting at the foothills of Caradhras; thinking about
which door to take in Moria ((holds a pipe talking w/Elrond, but doesn't smoke
it))
509) Frodo and Pippin have collarless shirts, and Sam and Merry have shirts
with collars; Pippin is the only one of the hobbits who doesn't wear a vest.
Sam's is grey (pin striped, Frodo's is burgundy, and Merry's is yellow); each
of the hobbits Shire cloaks close a different way (ties, buttons, etc.) and are
different colors; Pippin's the only hobbit wearing a scarf.
510) Pippin has a side bag slung across his shoulder and Merry has a backpack.
Frodo has a backpack and Sam is loaded down with a huge backpack, 2 pans, one
ladle, a cooking pot, a water bag hangs down below, a bedroll and there are
sausages strung around the outside of all. He's also carrying a side bag over
his shoulder. He can still keep up with the rest hauling three times their
load.
511) While the orcs in Moria and in the prologue all seem to have very
individualized arms and armor, as though they scavenged or made it all
themselves over time, the orcs coming out of Isengard are an "insta-army": most
of their weapons and armor was made at the same time, and is more uniform.
512) While Boromir’s horse wears heavy, elaborate tack, Legolas’s horse and
Asfaloth are lightly bridled and saddled, with the same sort of buckles on
their bridles (and all the elven horses seen so far have been grey). The Nazgul
horses look like they took hours to be readied - all chains and straps and
leather, with the straps on the bridle buckling upside-down (with the ends of
the strap pointing up instead of down) - and like it was done carelessly: the
fabric of the hood under their head armor is rucked up and wrinkled.
513) Merry was constantly eating apples: At Bilbo's party stealing fireworks;
at the foothills of Caradhras learning how to sword fight; at Weathertop
getting his dagger from Aragorn; at Rivendell when reunited with Frodo; and he
catches, but doesn't eat, an apple outside Bree in the wild.
514) It looks like there's references of the players personalities in the film:
Elijah roughing up his clothes when packing (admits to being messy); Sean
Bean's saying Narsil is still sharp referencing his Sharpe series; maybe
Orlando surfing down the stairs on a shield from him snowboarding and
watersurfing all the time (?)
I also noticed most of the reel change markers in the theater showings (small
circle in the upper right-hand corner of the screen about every 20 minutes or
so).
1- Gandalf busts Merry & Pippin after the firework goes off.
2- Gandalf and Saruman walk the grounds of Isengard
3- Weathertop when Aragorn hands out the swords
4- Rivendell when Strider looks up at Boromir at the shards of Narsil.
5- Left Caradhras just before approaching the water where the watcher
sleeps.
6- Cut to Strider (confused look on his face) in Khazad-dum when the Balrog is
first heard.
7- Uruk-hai leaving Isengard, Fellowship leaving Lothlorien.
8- Lurtz is
beheaded
~ ? ~ ? ~ ? ~ ? ~ ? ~ ? ~ ? ~ ? ~ ? ~ ? ~ ? ~ ? ~ ? ~ ? ~ ? ~ ? ~? ~ ? ~ ? ~ ? ~ ? ~ ? ~
“I can’t think somehow that Gandalf would have sent Mr. Frodo on this errand, if there hadn’t a’ been any hope of his ever coming back at all. Things all went wrong when he went down in Moria. I wish he hadn’t. He would have done something.”
*You know you're Tolkien geek when:
You think if you stare at that tree long enough, it'll blink first.
You carry your aspirin perched in the palm of your hand like the one ring.
You wear your bathrobe cloaked around you like you're veiling hidden powers!
You've cut thumbholes in all your sweaters.*
~Hug like a Hobbit~
"He's cool like an elf; he's got the heart of a hobbit; and he's mad like a wizard" (Orlando describes Peter)
TRUST PETER