Lord of the Fans
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Our Sponsor Sideshow/Weta Collectibles
Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Links
Home
The Movies
Fan Reviews
Line Party
Movie FAQ
Preview
Characters
Cast
Crew
Locations
Release
Scrap Book
Special Effects
Spy Reports
Features
NZ Exclusives
Xoanon's Rants
Tehanu's Notes
Newsroom
Glaurung's Hoard
Interviews
Script Review
Barlimans
Java Chat
Rules
Instructions
The IRC FAQ
Hall of Fire
Barliman's Polls
The Regulars
Chat Extras
Discussion
New Boards
Main
Reading Room
Movie Discussion
The Arena
Gaming
Feedback
Fan Section
Gaming Havens
Green Books
Community
Shop
Newbie Guide
Archives
News Archives
Spy Archives
Shop Archives
Barli Archives
Fan Archives
Special Reports
Site Info
Site Map
Contact Us
Mailing Lists
Charities
Banners
Contests
Polls
Links
Advanced Search
FAQ
Staff
Awards
Advertising
TBHL

Help Support
TheOneRing.net

Donate Via Amazon
Join the Hall of Fire Mailing list!

This Week's Topic
To be announced.
Next Week's Topic
To be announced.
When?
Saturday Chat:
21st Nov 2009 5:30pm ET
[also 11:30pm CET and 7:30am Sunday AEST]
Sunday Chat:
22nd Nov 2009 8:00pm CET
[also 2:00pm EST and 4:00am Monday AEST]

ET Eastern Time,
USA's East Coast
BST British Summer Time,
GMT+1 hour
AET Australian Eastern Time,
Australia's East Coast

Past Discussions
November - December 1999
January - December 2000
January - December 2001
January - December 2002
January - December 2003
January - December 2004
January - December 2005
January - December 2006
January - December 2007
January - December 2008
January - November 2009
The Hall of Fire - Scholarly Study of all things Tolkien


Frodo found himself walking with Gandalf. 'This is the Hall of Fire' said the wizard. 'Here you will hear many songs and tales - if you can keep awake. But except on high days it usually stands empty and quiet, and people come here who wish for peace, and thought.' The Fellowship of the Ring, Book II, Chapter 1 Many Meetings.

Welcome to the TheOneRing.net's Hall of Fire! Like its namesake from Lord of the Rings, the Hall is for storytelling, lore-study and discussion.

Each weekend, we gather to discuss (and occasionally argue!) over the topic of the week. And whether it's debating the pros and cons of Peter Jackson's films, going into the Silmarillion in depth, or simply sharing our ideas about why we love Tolkien and LoTR, you're more than welcome to come along and join in!

We also occasionally have special guests drop in for extended Q&A sessions - so keep an eye out for announcements about those!

Hall of Fire currently is held every weekend on alternating Saturdays and Sundays, with chats lasting anywhere between 45 minutes and an hour and a half depending on the topic. You can check out the start times over on the right, and if it's not listed for your timezone, drop us a line and we'll help you out.

Where do I go to join in?
Hall of Fire chats happen on irc.theonering.net - the TORn IRC server - in the channel (or room) #thehalloffire. If you're an IRC newbie, you can easily jump on via our
java chat client that works inside your web browser. Simply choose #thehalloffire on the drop down box, enter a nick and you'll be in the channel within seconds!

Alternatively, you can install a dedicated IRC program such as mIRC. To find out more about using mIRC to connect to the TORn IRC server, check out these instructions.

Submit a topic idea
If you have a burning desire to discuss something in Hall of Fire, drop us a line with your topic at halloffire@theonering.net.
If we like it, we'll probably give it a run in the coming weeks - you
might even be invited to guest moderate the session!

Our discussion guidelines
TheOneRing.net's chatrooms are a place for good conversation about J.R.R. Tolkien's works. We welcome you to our community and ask that you, and all guests, abide by these simple guidelines:

Please be specific to Hall of Fire: Each session focuses on a particular topic, and people understandably get confused and annoyed when someone drops in and asks something totally off topic. We also request you don't use sounds, actions or scripts while Hall of fire is in sesion.

Please be courteous. Boorish behavior will not be tolerated, and we request you do not swear, curse, or harass other guests.

Think before you "speak". Use common sense - this is a world-wide chat, between many cultures and age levels.

Please respect others and their ideas. Be friendly and patient with each other. After all, we are just having fun!

No bots, spamming or flooding! No image banners or advertisements for other sites are permitted.

The op is always right! If your behavior or language is deemed inappropriate by an op, you will be warned or even removed from the room. Frequent violations may result in you being banned from the channel or even the server.

Past Discussions

Discussions in 2005
01/08 The Power of Song
01/16 The Silmarillion: Ainulindale
01/23 The Silmarillion: the Valaquenta
01/29 The Silmarillion: Chapter One
02/06 The Silmarillion: Chapter Two & Three
02/12 The Silmarillion: Chapter Four & Five
02/19 The Silmarillion: Chapter Six
02/26 Stories never told ...
03/06 Stories never told ...
03/12 The Silmarillion: Chapter Seven
03/20 The Silmarillion: Chapter Seven
03/26 Pippin Took - bold hard halfling or piece of luggage?
04/03 Pippin Took - bold hard halfling or piece of luggage?
04/09 The Silmarillion: Chapter Eight
04/17 The Silmarillion: Chapter Eight
04/23 Tell us your LoTR fan experience!
05/01 Tell us your LoTR fan experience!
05/07 The Silmarillion: Chapter Nine
05/14 Peter Lyon & Kirin Shah Live Chat
05/15 The Silmarillion: Chapter Nine
05/21 Is LoTR unfilmable? Was Tolkien right?
05/29 Is LoTR unfilmable? Was Tolkien right?
06/04 Star Wars and LoTR
06/12 Star Wars and LoTR
06/18 Special guest Q&A - Kiran Shah
06/26 What if Gollum lived?
07/02 What if Gollum lived?
07/10 The Silmarillion: Chapter Ten
07/16 The Silmarillion: Chapter Ten
07/30 Theoden: King of the Mark
08/07 Theoden: King of the Mark
08/13 The Silmarillion: Chapter Eleven
08/21 The Silmarillion: Chapter Eleven
08/27 Elrond, Cirdan and Isildur at the Ring of Doom
09/04 Elrond, Cirdan and Isildur at the Ring of Doom
09/10 The Silmarillion: Chapter Twelve
09/18 The Silmarillion: Chapter Twelve
09/24 The Silmarillion: Chapter Thirteen
10/02 The Silmarillion: Chapter Thirteen
10/08 Merry, Pippin, Gimli and Legolas essential?
10/16 Merry, Pippin, Gimli and Legolas essential?
10/22 The Silmarillion Chapter 14
10/30 The Silmarillion Chapter 14
11/05 Live Chat with Alan Lee
11/12 The Seven Deadly Sins of LOTR
11/20 The Seven Deadly Sins of LOTR
11/26 Silmarillion Ch 15
12/04 The Silmarillion Ch 15
12/10 The Seven Heavenly Virtues of LOTR
12/17 Ringers: Lord of the Fans

Discussions in 2004
01/03 Aragorn's Portrayal in RoTK
01/11 Jackson's LoTR Trilogy
01/18 RoTK - The Whine and Cheese Party
01/24 Villians in RoTK
01/31 Frodo, Sam and Gollum
02/08 Little Engimas of LoTR
02/14 A Chance Meeting
02/22 The Hobbit: Ch 1
03/06 The Hobbit: Ch 2
03/13 The Hobbit: Ch 3
03/21 The Hobbit: Ch 4
03/27 Tolkien and Technology
04/03 The Hobbit: Ch 5
04/10 Cinematic Possibilities of the Hobbit
04/18 The Hobbit: Ch 6
04/24 Tolkien and Environmentalism
05/02 The Hobbit: Ch 7
05/09 The Hobbit: Ch 8
05/15 Tolkien's Creatures - Origins
05/22 Relationships in LoTR
05/29 The RoTK DVD
06/05 The Hobbit: Ch 9
06/12 Galadriel
06/19 Themes in PJ's Lord of the Rings
06/26 Dwarves in the Fourth Age
07/03 The Hobbit: Ch 10
07/10 Magic in Middle-earth
07/17 Powerful Objects in ME
07/24 Gandalf and Hobbits
07/31 Middle-earth's Greatest Cities
08/07 Hall of Fire takes a break!
08/14 The Hobbit: Ch 11&12
08/21 The Valar’s Intervention in ME
08/28 Samwise Gamgee
09/04 The Hobbit: Ch 13
09/11 Middle Earth's Greatest Hero
09/18 The Hobbit: Ch 14
09/25 The Downfall of Numenor
10/02 The Hobbit: Ch 15
10/09 Tom Bombadil
10/16 The Hobbit: Ch 16
10/23 Political Systems of Middle-earth
10/30 The Nazgul!
11/07 HoF Hosts Anne Petty!
11/13 The Hobbit: Ch 17
11/20 If I lived in Middle-earth
11/27 The Hobbit: Ch 18 & 19
12/04 Concerning Hobbits
12/11 HoF Hosts David Salo
12/18 ROTK Extended Edition
12/26 Share Your Story: 'What Tolkien Means to Me'

Discussions in 2003
01/04 The Whine and Cheese Party
01/11 The Movie Characterisation of Faramir
01/18 Frodo, the One Ring, and Controlling Gollum
01/25 Arwen's Choice
02/01 RoTK: Bk 5, Chap 1
02/08 CGI in the Two Towers
02/15 Oscar Nominations Roundup
02/22 Acting in the Two Towers
03/01 RoTK: Bk 5, Chap 2
03/09 Isildur
03/15 RoTK: Bk 5, Chap 3
03/22 RoTK: Bk 5, Chap 4
03/30 You Direct RoTK!
04/05 RoTK: Bk 5, Chap 5
04/12 Stewards of Middle Earth
04/19 The Druedain
04/26 Ents, Entwives and all things Treeish
05/03 RoTK: Bk 5, Chap 6
05/11 Denethor, Steward of Gondor
05/18 RoTK: Bk 5, Chap 7
05/24 The Valar, wise counsels ...?
05/31 RoTK: Bk 5, Chap 8
06/07 Sauron the Deceiver
06/14 RoTK: Bk 5, Chap 9
06/21 Greatest Culture
06/28 Sauron and the Rings of Power
07/05 RoTK: Bk 5, Chap 10
07/12 Trees and Tolkien
07/19 Tooks and Brandybucks
07/26 What fascinates you most about Middle-earth?
08/02 RoTK: Bk 6, Chapter 1
08/09 Tolkien and the canon
08/16 RoTK, Book 6, Chapter 2
08/24 Colours in Tolkien's world
08/30 Movie spoilers: Love 'em or hate 'em?
09/07 Feanor, Spirit of Fire
09/13 Rotk Book 6, Ch 3
09/20 Tolkien and the 21st Century
09/27 RoTK Book 6, Ch 4
10/04 Leaf by Niggle
10/11 The RoTK Trailer!
10/18 RoTK Book 6, Ch 5
10/25 Hobbit Resistance to the One
11/01 RoTK Book 6, Ch 6
11/08 Tale of Aragorn and Arwen
11/15 RoTK: Book 6, Ch 7
11/22 Durin's Folk
11/29 RoTK: Book 6, Ch 8
12/06 TTT - Extended Edition
12/13 RoTK: Book 6, Ch 9
12/20 RoTK - the Movie
12/27 Denethor

Discussions in 2002
01/05 What Did You Miss in the Movie?
01/12 Saruman's Role in the Movie
01/19 Purists' Whine & Cheese Party
01/26 Was the movie newbie-friendly?
02/02 Arwen & Aragorn
02/09 Elijah Wood's portrayal of Frodo
02/16 The Academy Awards
02/23 Reputed Errors
03/02 FoTR DVD: Anticipated features
03/09 TTT: Bk 3, Chap 1
03/16 Balrog Wings: Was the Movie Correct?
03/23 Nature of the Ring of Power
03/30 The Two Towers Preview Screener
04/06 TTT: Bk 3, Chap 2
04/13 LoTR: race and class stereotypes
04/20 The Two Towers: The Movie
04/27 Literary merits of LoTR as an adult book
05/04 Guide to Reading The Silm.
05/11 Tolkien: Creator of Modern Fantasy?
05/18 TTT: Bk 3, Chap 3
05/25 Effect of War of the Ring on Frodo
06/01 The evolution of Tolkien's writing
06/08 TTT: Bk 3, Chap 4
06/15 Responsibility of Elves to ME
06/22 TTT: Bk 3, Chap 5
06/29 TTT: Bk 3, Chap 6
07/06 Pippin Took: Bold, hard halfling...?
07/13 TTT: Bk 3, Chap 7
07/20 Catholicism and Tolkien's writings.
07/27 TTT: Bk 3, Chap 8
08/03 Éowyn, the White Lady of Rohan
08/10 TTT: Bk 3, Chap 9
08/17 TTT: Bk 3, Chap 10
08/24 TTT: Bk 3, Chap 11
09/01 The Hobbit vs LoTR
09/08 TTT: Bk 4, Chap 1
09/15 TTT: Bk 4, Chap 2
09/22 The Hero and the Heroic in LoTR
09/28 TTT: Bk 4, Chap 3
10/06 TTT: Bk 4, Chap 4
10/12 TTT Trailer Discussion
10/20 TTT: Bk 4, Chap 5
10/26 TTT: Bk 4, Chap 6
11/02 TTT: Bk 4, Chap 7
11/09 TTT: Bk 4, Chap 8
11/16 Palantiri Q&A
11/23 TTT: Bk 4, Chap 9
11/30 Gender imbalances in LoTR
12/07 TTT: Bk 4, Chap 10
12/14 Two Towers Movie Preview
12/21 Two Towers - the Movie
12/28 TTT Movie Changes

Discussions in 2001
01/13 The Physical Abilities of Men and Elves
01/27 No other author close to JRR Tolkien?
02/11 Tolkien Enigmas
02/17 FOTR Chapter 1
02/24 Tolkien Fan Creations
03/03 FOTR Chapter 2
03/10 Industrialization and Tolkien/ME
03/17 FOTR Chapter 3
03/24 Sauron the Movies and Me
03/31 FOTR Chapter 4
04/07 Tolkien and Allegory
04/14 FOTR Chapter 5
04/21 Women in JRRT's Middle Earth
04/28 FOTR Chapter 6
05/05 Arwen Evenstar
05/12 FOTR Chapter 7
05/19 Can appreciate movie w/o Book?
05/26 FOTR Chapter 8
06/02 Lurtz
06/09 FOTR Chapter 9
06/16 Hobbits
06/23 FOTR Chapter 10
06/30 Human Warriors
07/14 The Movie Trailer
07/21 FOTR Chapter 12
07/28 Christopher Tolkien
08/04 FOTR, Bk 2, Chap 1
08/11 Merchandizing
08/18 FOTR, Bk 2, Chap 2
08/25 The Silmarillion
09/01 FOTR, Bk 2, Chap 3
09/08 News and Rumors
09/15 Sept 11, 2001
09/22 FOTR, Bk 2, Chap 4
09/29 Trailer II
10/06 Aragorn
10/13 Orc Breeding
10/20 FOTR, Bk 2, Chap 5
10/27 The Cast
11/03 FOTR, Bk 2, Chap 6
11/10 FOTR, Bk 2, Chap 7
11/17 FOTR, Bk 2, Chap 8
11/24 The Score
12/01 FOTR, Bk 2, Chap 9
12/08 FOTR, Bk 2, Chap 10
12/15 FOTR, review [Book]
12/22 FOTR, review [Movie Pt 1]
12/29 FOTR, review [Movie Pt 2]

Discussions in 2000
01/09 The One Ring
01/15 LotR Highlights
01/22 Tolkien Q&A
01/29 The Silmarils
02/05 Blade in Frodo's Heart
02/12 Tolkien Inspirations
02/19 ME's Greatest Hero
02/26 Characters Living With Us Today?
03/04 Scariest Moment?
03/11 The Fate of the Orcs
03/18 Favorite History?
03/26 Istari Part 1
04/08 Racism in ME
04/15 Favorite Arda Moments
04/22 Frodo, Hobbit of Shire
04/29 Internet Preview
05/06 Supporting Characters
05/13 Eye Witness in Middle-earth
05/20 The Silmarillion on Film
05/27 Manipulating ME History
06/03 Art and Tolkien
06/10 LoTR and Hobbit Productions
06/17 Tolkien Q&A, Part II
06/24 Gimli Son of Gloin
07/01 Middle-earth Skills
07/08 Magic in Middle-Earth
07/15 Elves, Men, Death and Tolkien
07/22 Legolas Greenleaf: Elf of Mirkwood
07/29 Music in Middle-earth
08/05 Legacy of Tolkien's Work on Film
08/12 Boromir: Tragic Hero of Gondor
08/19 Middle-earth's Baddest Bad Guy
08/26 Middle-earth and Human History
09/02 Middle-earth Memorabilia
09/09 Spend a day with a ME Character
09/16 Reading Hobbit/LoTR for the first time
09/23 The Hobbit
09/30 Samwise Gamgee
10/14 Fate vs. Free Will
10/28 Favourite Battle
11/11 Tolkien and Religion, Part I
11/25 Tolkien and Religion, Part II
12/09 Did Frodo Fail His Quest?

Discussions in 1999
11/13 Glorfindel
11/20 Tom Bombadil
11/27 What Would Gollum Have Done
12/04 Balrog Wings
12/11 Nine Rings
12/18 Someone Else?

The Moderators


Loressar
Loressar
Alquawen
Alquawen
Demosthenes
Demosthenes
mallorn
mallorn
  Maegwen
maegwen
  Po
Po
  Frode
Frode

The Ranks of the Fallen
Nazfyratu
Nazfyratu
Tookish
Tookish
Mormegil
Mormegil
Jincey
Jincey
Strider
Strider
Leo
Leo
RingLass
RingLass
Melian
Melian

home | advertising |contact us | back to top | site map | search | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2007 TheOneRing®.net. TheOneRing® is a registered service mark with exclusive right to grant use assigned to The One Ring, Inc. Unique Design by DesignHeroes.com Custom Programming by Angel Web Solutions

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap. Do not send email to this address, it will be reported as spam.